Blog

How do I get reimbursed for an out-of-network therapist with a superbill?

From checking out-of-network mental health benefits to filing a superbill, with a worked example: $150 sessions, a $500 deductible and 60% reimbursement.

If your therapist does not take your insurance, you can often still get part of the fee back, but the plan will not do it automatically. You pay the therapist, the therapist gives you a document called a superbill, and you send it to your plan as a claim. Whether anything comes back depends on one question you can answer before the first session: does your plan have out-of-network benefits for outpatient mental health care, and how much of the deductible is left?

This walkthrough follows one process from start to finish, with a worked example. The numbers are invented and rounded to make the arithmetic visible. They are not a prediction for any plan.

Step 1: find out whether your plan pays for out-of-network therapy at all

Plan type decides most of this. A PPO plan and many point-of-service plans cover care from out-of-network providers at a lower rate. An HMO or an EPO often covers out-of-network care only in an emergency, unless the plan approves an exception. Look in your summary of benefits and coverage for the row labeled something like "outpatient mental health" or "mental/behavioral health outpatient services," and read the out-of-network column.

Then call the number on your card and ask these questions. Write down the date, the representative's name and a reference number.

  1. Do I have out-of-network benefits for outpatient psychotherapy (the visit itself, not only inpatient care)?
  2. Is there a separate out-of-network deductible, and how much of it have I met this plan year?
  3. After the deductible, what percentage does the plan pay, and is it a percentage of my therapist's fee or of the plan's own allowed amount?
  4. Is there a limit on the number of visits, or does the plan require approval after a certain number?
  5. Is there a separate out-of-network out-of-pocket maximum?
  6. How do I submit a claim, by what deadline, and does the plan accept it through a portal?
  7. If the claim is paid, who receives the payment?

Question 3 deserves special attention. Plans usually pay a percentage of what they call the allowed amount, which is their own figure for what the service is worth. For out-of-network care, that figure can be lower than the therapist's fee. The difference is yours to pay, because an out-of-network provider can bill you for the difference. The guide on how out-of-network claims work: allowed amounts and balance bills covers how that works.

Step 2: ask the therapist for three things before you start

Many therapists who do not take insurance are used to this and will provide a superbill monthly or after each session. Ask whether they will, how they bill (per session or monthly), and what the cancellation terms are. Ask them also what diagnosis code they will put on the claim. A mental health diagnosis code is needed for the plan to process the claim, and it becomes part of your insurance record, so you may want to talk about that with the therapist openly.

If you have not yet picked a therapist, check whether an in-network one is available at a reasonable wait, because the cost difference can be large. The guide on how to find an in-network therapist, and what to do when none exist explains how to check a plan's directory and what to do when the directory is out of date.

Step 3: know what a superbill contains

A superbill is an itemized receipt in the format an insurer expects. It is not a claim form, but it holds what a claim needs. Most plans want these elements:

  • The provider's name, address, license type and license number.
  • The provider's National Provider Identifier (NPI) and tax identification number.
  • Your name, date of birth, address and member ID.
  • The date of each session.
  • A procedure code for each session. These are standard billing codes for the type and length of service, such as an initial evaluation or a 45-minute or 60-minute session. Your therapist assigns them, and you should not change them.
  • A diagnosis code for the reason for care.
  • The fee charged for each session and the amount you paid.
  • The place of service, which tells the plan whether the visit was in an office or by telehealth.

If something is missing, the plan may deny the claim for incomplete information, which costs weeks. Check the superbill against your plan's claim instructions before you send it. A therapist cannot invent a license number or code to fit the plan, and you should not ask.

Step 4: pay the therapist and keep proof

Pay the fee as the therapist's practice requires and keep the receipt, because the superbill usually shows the amount charged and a separate record shows the amount paid. If you pay with a health savings account or a flexible spending account card, ask whether the therapist's practice qualifies. Therapy is generally a qualified medical expense, but the plan administrator can confirm.

Step 5: submit the claim

Look for a member form, often called an out-of-network claim form or a medical claim form, on your plan's website. Fill it in, attach the superbill, and send it by the method the plan lists. Many plans accept uploads through the member portal, which gives a confirmation. Keep a copy of everything and a note of the date.

Pay attention to the deadline for filing. Plans set a time limit, often measured from the date of service, and a claim that arrives late can be refused. The plan's documents state the limit. Do not wait to batch a year of sessions into one claim, because the earliest ones may have expired.

Some plans accept a monthly batch, which saves effort. Others want a claim per visit. Ask which.

Step 6: read the explanation of benefits and follow up

After processing, the plan sends an explanation of benefits. It is not a bill. It shows the amount charged, the amount the plan allowed, what it applied to your deductible, what it paid and what you owe. The guide on How to read an explanation of benefits (EOB) line by line walks through each column.

If the claim is paid, the check or deposit usually goes to the member, not the therapist, because the therapist is not in the network. If you have not heard in about a month, call and ask for the claim status using the reference number. If it is denied, read the stated reason. A denial for missing information can be fixed and resubmitted. A denial for a plan exclusion or a visit limit can be appealed, and the denial letter states how.

A worked example

Say Alex sees a therapist who charges $150 per weekly session and does not take insurance. Alex's plan is a PPO. These are the plan's terms in this illustration:

  • A separate out-of-network deductible of $500, none yet met.
  • After the deductible, the plan pays 60% of the allowed amount.
  • In this first example, the plan's allowed amount equals the therapist's fee of $150.

Sessions 1 to 3. Each session is $150 and counts toward the deductible. After three sessions, $450 of the $500 has been met, and the plan has paid nothing. Alex has paid $450. The remaining deductible is $50.

Session 4. The first $50 goes to the deductible. The remaining $100 is covered at 60%, so the plan pays $60 and Alex owes the other $40. Alex's cost for the session is $50 + $40 = $90. The plan pays $60, and the check back to Alex is $60.

Sessions 5 to 8. The deductible is met. The plan pays 60% of $150 = $90 per session, and Alex's share is $60 per session.

Totals after eight sessions: the therapist has been paid 8 × $150 = $1,200. The plan has paid $60 + (4 × $90) = $420. Alex's net cost is $450 + $90 + (4 × $60) = $780. Check: $780 + $420 = $1,200.

A second version with a lower allowed amount. Say the plan's allowed amount for this service is $120, not $150. The deductible is credited with the allowed amount, or in some plans with the amount charged. Ask which. Suppose it uses the allowed amount, so each session counts $120 toward the deductible. After four sessions, $480 is met. In session 5, the first $20 finishes the deductible, then 60% of the remaining $100 allowed is $60, and the plan pays $60. Alex pays the therapist's $150 fee and receives $60, so the net cost is $90 for that session. In the sixth session and after, the plan pays 60% × $120 = $72, and Alex's net cost is $150 − $72 = $78. The gap between $150 and $120 never counts toward the deductible, and Alex keeps paying it. This is why asking question 3 matters.

What this shows. In the first third of the year the plan seems to pay nothing, which discourages some people. Over a longer course of therapy the reimbursement is real, but it is partial. If Alex's visits were every other week, the deductible would take twice as long to meet.

When the plan will not pay, or no in-network therapist is available

If your plan has no out-of-network benefits and you cannot find an in-network therapist with an opening, ask the plan for a network gap exception. Some plans will treat an out-of-network therapist as in-network, usually for a defined number of visits, when the plan cannot show that an in-network provider is available within a reasonable time or distance. You ask the plan, in writing, and keep the evidence: the names of in-network therapists you called and what you were told. This is a request, not a right in every plan, and the answer depends on your plan and your state's rules. Your state insurance department can say what applies to your plan.

You may also have protections about how a plan handles mental health benefits compared with medical ones. The post on How can I check my plan documents for unequal mental health limits? explains what to look for in your plan documents.

Mistakes that leave money on the table

  • Starting without asking about the deductible. The first sessions may be entirely out of pocket.
  • Assuming the plan pays a percentage of the fee. It usually pays a percentage of its own allowed amount.
  • Losing receipts. The superbill and a payment record both matter.
  • Filing late. Deadlines run from the date of service in many plans.
  • Treating a phone answer as a promise. Benefits quoted by phone are not a guarantee of payment, so write down who said what, and ask for confirmation in writing when you can.
  • Forgetting taxes and accounts. Unreimbursed therapy costs may be payable from an HSA or FSA and may count toward a medical expense deduction in some cases. A tax professional can say whether your situation qualifies.

Where to take the question next

The plan's member services answers benefit questions. The therapist's office answers codes and superbill content. A navigator or a licensed broker can help you compare plans at open enrollment if out-of-network mental health care is a priority, and the guide on does health insurance cover therapy and mental health care? explains what plans usually cover. Your state insurance department takes complaints when a plan misstates its benefits.

Key takeaways

  • A superbill is a receipt in insurance format, and you, not the therapist, file the claim with your plan.
  • Before the first session, ask whether you have out-of-network benefits, what the separate deductible is, whether the percentage applies to the fee or the allowed amount, and the filing deadline.
  • In the worked example, a $150 session with a $500 deductible and 60% reimbursement leaves Alex paying $780 of $1,200 after eight sessions; the plan pays $420.
  • A lower allowed amount than the therapist's fee leaves you paying the gap on every session.
  • If no in-network therapist is available in a reasonable time, you can ask the plan for a network exception, in writing.

Terms used in this guide

Related guides

Latest on this topic