Blog
How can I check my plan documents for unequal mental health limits?
A grouped checklist of where unequal treatment of therapy and psychiatric care hides in a plan, how to ask for the plan's analysis, and where to complain.
Many people notice the problem before they can name it. A $20 copay to see a family doctor, a $60 copay to see a therapist. A cap of twenty therapy visits a year, with no cap on physical therapy for a knee. A request for sessions that needs a form every month, when a medical specialist's visits never do. Any one of these may be perfectly lawful. Together they can be a sign that the plan treats mental health and substance use care less favorably than medical care, which is what federal parity law is meant to prevent.
This checklist is for the person holding the plan documents who suspects that. It does not tell you whether your plan is breaking the law. Only a regulator or a court can decide that. What it does is help you find the places where unequal limits tend to hide, write down what you see, and put a specific question to the plan or the regulator.
What the law asks, in plain terms
The federal Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act, passed in 2008, applies when a health plan covers mental health or substance use disorder benefits at all. In that case the plan may not put tougher limits on those benefits than it puts on medical and surgical benefits of the same kind. The law sorts benefits into classifications such as inpatient in-network, inpatient out-of-network, outpatient in-network, outpatient out-of-network, emergency care and prescription drugs, and compares within each one. Separately, the Affordable Care Act lists mental health and substance use disorder services among the ten essential health benefits for individual and small-group plans. See the mental health parity law: what insurers must treat equally for the background.
Two kinds of limits matter here:
- Quantitative limits are numbers: copays, coinsurance, deductibles, caps on visits or days.
- Non-quantitative limits are rules about how care is approved and delivered: prior authorization, step therapy, the way the plan defines medical necessity, how it builds its network, how it sets what it pays providers.
The regulatory picture has not stood still. The federal rules that put the 2008 law into practice have been rewritten, and the government's position on enforcing parts of the newer rules has changed more than once. This post does not state what is being enforced today. The checklist below works either way, because it asks you to compare what the plan does to mental health care with what it does to comparable medical care, and to ask the plan to explain any gap. For the current rules and enforcement position, check with the U.S. Department of Labor for employer plans, with your state insurance department for insured plans, and with CMS for Medicaid and Medicare materials.
Before you start: gather the documents
You need more than the card in your wallet. Collect these and keep them in one folder:
- The summary of benefits and coverage. It is short and standardized, which makes it good for a first comparison.
- The full plan document, called the evidence of coverage, certificate of coverage or summary plan description. It holds the limits and exclusions that the summary leaves out.
- Your explanations of benefits for the past year, for both mental health and medical visits.
- Any denial letters, approval letters and utilization review notices you have received.
- A screenshot or printout of the provider directory pages you searched, with the date.
Why bother: a complaint that says "my therapy costs more" is easy to dismiss. A complaint that says "page 41 of the certificate sets a 30-visit limit on outpatient mental health, and page 38 sets none on outpatient physical therapy" is something a regulator can act on.
Checklist 1: money you pay at the visit
Compare the amount you pay for outpatient mental health visits with the amount you pay for comparable outpatient medical visits. Check:
- Copay for a therapy visit versus a primary care visit and a specialist visit. Why: plans often charge a therapist the specialist rate. That may be defensible when the plan's own rules treat all specialist-type outpatient visits the same, and questionable when it does not.
- Coinsurance on mental health services versus medical services. Why: a 30% coinsurance on psychiatry next to 20% on other specialists is a number you can point to.
- Whether a separate deductible applies to mental health. Why: a deductible that applies only to behavioral health care, or that sits on top of the medical deductible, is a classic sign of unequal treatment. Under parity rules a separate deductible is a red flag.
- Whether the plan counts your mental health spending toward the same out-of-pocket maximum as your medical spending. Why: the plan should have one maximum, not a second one for behavioral health. See cost sharing.
- Different cost sharing in different settings. Why: an intensive outpatient program may be charged like a hospital day while a comparable medical outpatient program is charged like an office visit.
Here is a hypothetical, with round invented numbers. A plan charges $25 for a primary care visit, $50 for any specialist visit and $70 for an outpatient therapy visit. The $70 is higher than both. That is worth a written question. A plan that charges $50 for both a specialist and a therapist has a different story: the copays match the specialist tier, and the question becomes whether that tier is the right comparison. The plan should be able to say which medical benefits it compared and why.
Checklist 2: limits on how much care you can get
Look for numbers that cap treatment:
- Annual or lifetime visit limits on outpatient therapy, with no matching cap on comparable medical visits. Why: since the ACA, essential health benefits in individual and small-group plans can't carry annual or lifetime dollar limits, and a visit cap on therapy next to no cap on medical visits is a clear comparison.
- Day limits on inpatient psychiatric stays or residential treatment. Why: a hospital stay for pneumonia rarely comes with a fixed number of days written in advance.
- Limits that restart or shrink by diagnosis. Why: some plans allow more visits for one condition than another without a clinical reason in the document.
- Frequency limits, such as one session a week, in a plan that sets none on medical therapies.
- Exclusions by condition or by treatment type listed in the "what is not covered" section. Why: exclusions that read broadly for behavioral health and narrowly for medical care deserve a second look.
A limit that exists on both sides is not automatically a problem. Many plans cap physical therapy visits too. The comparison is what counts.
Checklist 3: approval rules and prior authorization
These are the least visible limits, because they live in internal policies, not on the benefits summary. Ask:
- Does mental health care need prior authorization when comparable medical care does not? Common examples are intensive outpatient programs, psychological testing, and ongoing therapy past a certain number of sessions.
- How often must the provider send a "treatment plan" or clinical update to keep sessions approved? Why: a request every four sessions for therapy, next to a one-time approval for a year of cardiology follow-ups, is a pattern worth noting.
- Does the plan require you to try a cheaper or lower level of care first? That rule is step therapy for drugs and "fail-first" for services. A plan might require outpatient therapy to fail before it approves a residential stay. Ask whether it does the same for medical services of comparable intensity.
- How strict is the plan's medical necessity test? Ask for the criteria the plan uses. A plan may use a published clinical guideline for medical care and a narrower in-house one for behavioral health. You are entitled to see the criteria it applied to your denied claim.
- Does the plan require a referral or a primary care visit before a mental health appointment? Why: that is an extra step, and the plan should be able to say whether it asks the same for specialists in medicine.
- How long do reviews take, and how many are denied? Plans do not hand over denial rates to individuals, but a regulator can ask.
Checklist 4: the network
A plan can look equal on paper and be unequal in practice if you cannot find anyone to see. Test it:
- Search the directory for therapists and psychiatrists near you, then for cardiologists or dermatologists near you. Write down how many are listed in each group.
- Call a sample. Ten calls to listed therapists will tell you how many are taking new patients, how many are still in the network and how long the wait is. The term for a directory full of providers who cannot see you is a ghost network. See how to find an in-network therapist, and what to do when none exist for a calling script.
- Compare wait times. Note the date you asked and the first available appointment, for both mental health and medical specialists.
- Check the travel distance the plan sets as acceptable. network adequacy standards are set by state or federal rules and differ by plan type, and many plans use the same standard for all specialties. Ask whether the plan applies the same one to behavioral health.
- Ask what the plan does when no in-network provider is available within a reasonable time. Many plans have a network exception process that lets you see an out-of-network provider at in-network cost.
Why this belongs on a parity checklist: network design is one of the non-quantitative limits regulators look at. A network with a thin supply of therapists and a rich supply of medical specialists is a pattern worth documenting.
Checklist 5: provider pay, drugs and levels of care
You cannot see most of what the plan pays providers, but you can see its effects. Providers often say the plan pays them less for therapy than for a medical visit of the same length, which is one reason they leave networks. Signs you can observe:
- Many in-network therapists have stopped taking the plan.
- Providers tell you they accept only private pay or out-of-network billing.
- Your out-of-network reimbursement is a small fraction of what the therapist charges, and the plan's explanation of its "allowed amount" is vague. See How do I get reimbursed for an out-of-network therapist with a superbill? for how out-of-network claims work.
Ask the plan, in writing, how it sets reimbursement for behavioral health providers and whether the method differs from the one it uses for medical providers. The answer may be general. Put it in your log all the same.
Two more places to look:
- Medication for mental health conditions: do the drugs sit on higher tiers, or need prior authorization or step therapy, more often than comparable medical drugs? Ask what the plan's formulary exception process is.
- Residential, partial hospitalization and intensive outpatient levels: does the plan cover them, and under what criteria? A plan that covers a medical rehabilitation stay but excludes a comparable behavioral one is another comparison.
- Out-of-network coverage: does the plan cover out-of-network mental health care the way it covers out-of-network medical care? If it covers out-of-network medical specialists but not therapists, note it.
A table to keep your findings straight
Make a table of your own. Here is a layout, with example entries that are invented:
| Item | Mental health benefit | Comparable medical benefit | Page in plan document |
|---|---|---|---|
| Outpatient copay | $70 therapy visit | $50 specialist visit | 12 |
| Annual visit cap | 30 visits | none stated | 41 and 38 |
| Prior authorization | after visit 8 | none for follow-ups | 55 |
| Separate deductible | none | none | 10 |
Rows where the two columns differ are your questions. Rows where they match are fine and do not need a complaint.
Not every difference means a violation. The plan may be able to explain it with a medical or operational reason that applies to both sides. And a few matches do not prove the plan is in the clear, because the unequal part may be hidden in a policy you cannot see. That is why the next step is to ask the plan to show its work.
How to ask the plan for its analysis
Send a written request through the plan's member portal or by mail, and keep a copy. A short version might read:
I am a member (ID number) and I have questions about how my plan applies limits to mental health and substance use disorder benefits compared with medical and surgical benefits. Please send me the plan's written explanation of the non-quantitative treatment limits it applies to mental health benefits, the factors and evidence it used to design them, and the comparison it made with medical benefits. Please also send the clinical criteria used to review requests for [the service you need].
Some points to know about this request:
- Federal law requires plans to put together written comparative analyses of their non-quantitative limits and to hand them to regulators on request. Whether a plan gives a member the full analysis varies. Even a refusal is useful to record, because a regulator can then request the analysis itself.
- If you have been denied a claim, you have a right to the documents relevant to that claim, including the internal rules or guidelines the plan relied on. This right is part of the standard claims process and you do not need to cite parity law to use it. See how to appeal a denied health insurance claim, step by step.
- A fully insured plan answers to the state. A self-funded employer plan answers to the federal Department of Labor. Your plan document or HR office can tell you which kind you have. The plan's customer service line often cannot, so ask the employer.
Where to complain, and what to include
If the answer is missing, vague, or confirms a mismatch you think is unequal, file a complaint. how to file a complaint with your state insurance department walks through the process for state-regulated plans.
- Fully insured individual or employer plan: your state insurance department, usually through an online complaint form.
- Self-funded employer plan: the U.S. Department of Labor's Employee Benefits Security Administration. Its consumer assistance office can also answer questions about which rules apply.
- Medicaid managed care: the state Medicaid agency and the plan's own grievance process.
- Marketplace plans: the state insurance department; HealthCare.gov also lists complaint routes for federally run marketplaces.
A good complaint is short and has attachments. State who you are, what plan you have, the two or three specific differences from your table with page numbers, the date and result of any request to the plan, and what you want: a review of the limit, a change in how your claim is handled, or a response to the plan's reasoning. File a grievance with the plan at the same time if you want the plan's own process on record. A pending complaint does not stop you from appealing a denial in the meantime, and appeal deadlines keep running, so check the denial notice for yours.
If you or someone close to you is in crisis, get care first and sort out limits later. Emergency care has its own rules, covered in In a mental health crisis, what will insurance pay for at the ER or on 988?. If you need ongoing care and the plan is blocking it, ask your clinician's office to help request an urgent review or an exception, and ask the plan whether it offers care coordination for behavioral health. A state insurance department or a navigator can tell you whether a faster route exists in your state.
Key takeaways
- Parity law compares how a plan treats mental health and substance use care with how it treats medical care of the same kind. The question is always "compared with what?", so build a side-by-side table from the plan's own pages.
- Unequal limits can be numbers (copays, visit caps, separate deductibles) or rules (prior authorization, step therapy, narrow criteria, thin networks). The rules are harder to see, so ask the plan to explain them in writing.
- A difference is a question, not proof of a violation. Plans can sometimes justify it, and only a regulator or court decides.
- Rules and enforcement have changed since 2008 and may change again. Check current federal and state positions with the regulator before relying on any one of them.
- Keep the paper trail: documents, call notes, dates and replies. It is what turns a frustration into a complaint a regulator can act on.