Blog

What happens if I do nothing at my employer's open enrollment?

How passive rollover works, which benefits quietly drop off when you skip the benefits portal, and a five-minute check to run before the deadline closes.

The email from HR has been in your inbox for two weeks. The benefits portal needs a login you have to reset. You have the same plan you had last year and nothing in your life has changed, so you close the tab. Whether that works out fine or costs you real money depends on a single design choice your employer made, which you can find out in about five minutes.

Employers handle a silent employee in one of two ways. Under passive enrollment, the plan you already have continues for the next year without any action from you. Under active enrollment, you must log in and choose, and if you do not, you may end up with no election at all. Many employers use passive enrollment for medical coverage and active enrollment for the accounts and add-ons around it. This post explains the difference, what usually carries over and what usually does not, and what the cost of a mistake looks like.

Passive rollover and active enrollment

During open enrollment period at a job, the employer lets everyone covered by its plan change their elections for the coming plan year. If your employer runs passive enrollment, your medical, dental and vision elections roll over on the same terms if the plan still exists and the employer has not changed the offering. The plan document or the enrollment guide says which approach applies. If you cannot find it, HR can answer in a single sentence.

Active enrollment is more common than people expect, for three groups of benefits:

  • Flexible spending accounts and health savings account contributions. These are payroll elections. Under many employers' rules, the election you made last year ends on December 31 and a new election has to be made. No new election means $0 going in.
  • Dependent care accounts. Same reasoning.
  • Optional add-ons, such as disability insurance, life insurance above a basic amount or accident coverage, where the employer wants a fresh signature or a fresh decision each year.

The legal reason is the structure of the cafeteria plan, the arrangement that lets you pay premiums and fund accounts with pre-tax money. Federal rules for those plans require an election to be made before the plan year starts and to stay fixed during it, with exceptions for certain life events. An employer is allowed to carry an election forward automatically, sometimes called an evergreen election, but it is not required to, and some do and some do not. For plan year 2027 the health FSA limit is $3,500 and the HSA limit for self-only coverage is $4,500 (family $9,000). None of those limits matters if nothing is elected.

What usually carries over, and what usually does not

Treat this as a pattern, not a promise. The plan documents decide.

Benefit Common default if you do nothing What to check
Medical plan Same plan continues, if still offered Whether the plan, network or insurer changes for 2027
Dental and vision Same plan continues Premium changes and benefit-year limits
Health FSA Often lapses to $0 unless the employer uses an automatic election Whether you want to fund it, and the 2027 limit
Dependent care FSA Often lapses to $0 Whether your child care costs continue
HSA payroll contribution Often stops, or continues at last year's dollar amount Whether the amount fits the 2027 limit
Spouse or dependent coverage Continues, but eligibility may be re-verified Any surcharge, attestation or documents due
Voluntary life, disability, accident Varies Whether a new election or evidence of insurability is needed

If your employer treats a non-election as a decision to decline coverage, a different outcome follows. That is the one to rule out first. People who waived coverage in a prior year because they were on a spouse's plan are the group that most often discovers that a waiver has to be renewed annually, depending on the employer.

Case 1: the plan was discontinued

Employers change insurers and plans at renewal. If your current plan will not exist in 2027, passive enrollment has to map you to something. The mapping can be generous or not. A common version moves you to the closest replacement. Another puts you in the default plan, which may be a high-deductible plan with a different network. A third gives you no plan and treats you as having declined.

Why it matters: the closest replacement can differ from your current plan in deductible, network, prescription formulary and monthly cost. The summary of benefits and coverage for the plan you are about to be placed in will show the deductible and coinsurance side by side with the old plan. Your doctors may have a different network status. A quick check with the carrier's provider directory costs minutes, and the doctor, hospital and drug network check worksheet organizes it.

Some employers notify employees of the default in a separate letter. Look for that document under benefits in the employee portal or the HR mailbox before the deadline, because the whole point is that you are being placed somewhere.

Case 2: the premium changed and you did not look

Even a plan that continues unchanged can cost more. Employers renew their coverage every year and decide how much of the increase to pass on to employees. Premium deducted per paycheck is the most common surprise. Take a hypothetical employee paid twice a month whose share of the premium rises from $150 to $165 per paycheck (an illustration with round numbers). Each month that is $30 more. Over 24 paychecks:

  • Old annual cost: 24 x $150 = $3,600.
  • New annual cost: 24 x $165 = $3,960.
  • Increase: $3,960 - $3,600 = $360.

A silent election locks that in for the year. Open enrollment is also the time to reconsider whether the plan you have is the plan you need. Someone who used little care last year and hit no deductible might compare an alternative with a lower premium and a higher deductible. The how to compare health plans: premium, deductible, network and drugs guide shows the questions, and the deductible vs premium break-even calculator does the arithmetic.

Case 3: your account elections disappeared

This is the costliest silent mistake, because the opposite error of over-electing is already well known.

Say a hypothetical employee used a $2,000 health FSA in 2026 for contact lenses, copays and a dental procedure. With no new election in the portal, the employer's system sets the 2027 election to $0. Early in 2027 the employee goes to the dentist, pays $600 at the front desk and finds there is no account to reimburse it. The money would have saved about $600 x 22% = $132 in federal income tax at an assumed 22% bracket, plus any payroll tax savings. There is no way to elect an FSA in the middle of the year without a qualifying life event, so the savings are gone for the year.

The same applies to dependent care accounts and to HSA payroll contributions. An HSA is different in one respect: you can usually contribute directly to the account outside payroll and claim the deduction on your tax return, so the loss is the pre-tax payroll treatment rather than the contribution itself. The limit is the same either way. The FSA use-it-or-lose-it rules, carryover and grace periods guide explains why picking the amount carefully matters too, since FSA balances can be forfeited.

A real hazard runs the other way. In an employer plan with automatic carryover of last year's election, you may end up funding an FSA you no longer want, for example after a spouse loses a job or after the cost of child care ends. Check which kind of employer you have before assuming either direction.

Case 4: the dependent and spouse checks you skipped

Open enrollment is often where the employer verifies who is on the plan. Common requests:

  • Confirm that each dependent is still eligible. A child who has turned 26 generally leaves the plan, and a former spouse after a divorce cannot stay.
  • Attest to whether your spouse has access to their own employer's coverage. Some employers charge a spousal surcharge, an extra monthly amount, if the spouse could be on another plan and is not.
  • Attest to tobacco use or complete a wellness step to earn a premium discount.

A skipped attestation can mean the discount does not apply. A skipped document request can lead to a dependent removed from coverage mid-year. If you receive a notice like that after the deadline, the plan's own appeals or complaints process is where it goes, and the HR department can usually correct an error that is an employer mistake in processing.

What the penalty for forgetting looks like

Employers are not allowed to cancel coverage for no reason, and in a passive enrollment system doing nothing is rarely catastrophic for medical coverage. The practical cost of silence is usually one of these:

  1. Locked-in choices. You generally cannot change your plan, add an FSA or change a contribution amount in the middle of the year without a qualifying life event, such as marriage, birth, a change in a spouse's job or a loss of other coverage. The employer's plan document lists what counts.
  2. Missing accounts. The FSA, dependent care and HSA elections described above.
  3. A coverage gap, if the employer treats no election as declining. In that case, the options are those in Missed open enrollment? Your options for getting covered, and the marketplace remains available with its own deadlines: HealthCare.gov open enrollment for plan year 2027 runs November 1, 2026 to January 15, 2027, per CMS. Remember that an offer of affordable job-based coverage generally affects eligibility for marketplace premium tax credits, so a waived employer plan can mean a full-price marketplace plan.
  4. Higher costs you never reviewed. Premium increases, a different network or a new prescription tier.

A late request is sometimes possible. Employers can allow late changes for good cause, and an employer system error is a stronger case than forgetfulness. Ask HR in writing as soon as you notice, and keep the reply.

The five-minute check

Do these in order, today if your window is open.

  1. Find the deadline. Look in the HR email, the portal banner or the enrollment guide for the last day. Employers' windows differ, and many close in November or early December, but the date is theirs to set.
  2. Open the portal and read your current elections. Look for any line that says $0, waived or not enrolled.
  3. Read the notice on whether the plan changes. Search the benefits site for "2027 changes" or "renewal." Compare the deductible, network and per-paycheck cost with this year's.
  4. Re-enter the accounts. If you want an FSA, dependent care account or HSA contribution, set an amount. Remember the 2027 limits: FSA $3,500, HSA $4,500 self-only or $9,000 family, in each case for 2027.
  5. Confirm dependents and attestations. Check names, dates of birth and any surcharge or wellness items, then save a confirmation page or screenshot with the date.

That last step matters if anything goes wrong. A confirmation is your proof of what you elected and when. The open enrollment checklist and the open enrollment checklist: what to do before you pick a plan guide go further, and the how employer health insurance works: premiums, plan choices and rules guide explains the underlying employer plan basics. If the choice affects a household with more than one job, the post on marketplace open enrollment: the questions people ask in the first week covers the marketplace side of the same season.

Key takeaways

  • Whether silence rolls your medical plan over depends on the employer. Passive enrollment usually keeps the plan; active enrollment may leave you with no election.
  • FSA, dependent care and HSA payroll elections are the benefits most likely to drop to $0, and you generally cannot restart them mid-year without a qualifying life event.
  • A plan that continues can still cost more, so compare the per-paycheck premium, deductible and network with last year's.
  • A discontinued plan means a default placement or a lapse; find out which before the deadline.
  • Save a confirmation after every election, and ask HR in writing for a late correction if an employer error occurred.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic