By state and plan type · New York

Medigap (Medicare Supplement) insurers companies in New York

15 companies profiled on this site sell medigap policies in New York. Insurers that sell standardized Medigap policies that pay some of what Original Medicare does not.

Where to start in New York

Free Medicare counseling (SHIP)
HIICAP (Health Insurance Information, Counseling and Assistance Program), NYS Office for the Aging, 1-800-701-0501, https://aging.ny.gov/health-insurance-information-counseling-and-assistance-program-hiicap
Medigap rules in this state
Year-round guaranteed issue (continuous open enrollment) and community rating, per KFF; New York is one of only a few states (with Connecticut and Massachusetts) with continuous Medigap enrollment

Everything about health insurance in New York →

Companies that sell medigap policies in New York

Company Type Size Member line
UnitedHealthcareLargest U.S. health insurer by medical members: employer, Medicare and Medicaid plans, plus ACA individual plans in 29 states for 2027. National health insurers 49.8 million medical members (UnitedHealthcare, end of 2025) —
Aetna (CVS Health)CVS Health's insurance arm: employer, Medicare and Medicaid coverage; it left the ACA individual market after 2025. National health insurers 26.6 million medical members (year-end 2025) —
HumanaLouisville-based insurer centered on Medicare Advantage, with Part D, dental, vision, Medicaid and TRICARE contracts. It does not sell ACA marketplace plans. National health insurers About 7 million Medicare Advantage members, 20% of national Medicare Advantage enrollment (2026, KFF) —
HealthSpringMedicare plan brand of Health Care Service Corporation since 2025 (formerly Cigna Medicare): Medicare Advantage, Part D, Medigap and supplemental plans. Medicare Advantage and Medicare specialists About 700,985 Medicare Advantage members and 1.81 million stand-alone Part D members under the HealthSpring brand, plus 978,267 under Express Scripts Medicare (CMS, November 2026) 877-652-1739
AARP Medicare Supplement Insurance from UnitedHealthcareUnitedHealthcare's AARP-branded Medigap plans, sold under licence from AARP to AARP members; the largest Medigap program by enrollment. Medigap and senior market carriers 4.27 million Medigap members, 29.7% of the market (December 2025, Mark Farrah Associates) —
Mutual of OmahaPolicyholder-owned Nebraska insurer best known for Medicare Supplement; also sells dental, hospital indemnity and other supplemental coverage. Medigap and senior market carriers About 1.3 million Medigap members, 9.4% of the market (December 2025, Mark Farrah Associates) 800-775-6000
Aetna Medicare SupplementAetna, a CVS Health company, sells standardized Medicare Supplement (Medigap) policies to people on Original Medicare in many states. No provider network. Medigap and senior market carriers — 888-624-6290
TransamericaLife insurer owned by Aegon whose subsidiaries underwrite Medicare Supplement (Medigap) policies, plus life, retirement and worksite supplemental health. Medigap and senior market carriers — —
Colonial PennCNO Financial Group subsidiary best known for TV-marketed guaranteed-acceptance life insurance; it also sells Medicare Supplement (Medigap) plans. Medigap and senior market carriers — 877-877-8052
United American Insurance Company (Globe Life)Globe Life subsidiary in McKinney, Texas that has sold Medicare Supplement (Medigap) since 1966, mainly through independent agents. Medigap and senior market carriers — 800-331-2512
Globe LifeMcKinney, Texas holding company whose subsidiaries sell life, supplemental health (cancer, accident, hospital) and Medicare Supplement policies through agents. Short-term and supplemental carriers — 800-831-1200
Elevance Health (Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield, Wellpoint)Investor-owned insurer that holds Blue Cross and Blue Shield licenses in 14 states under Anthem names and sells Wellpoint plans elsewhere. National health insurers 45.2 million medical members (year-end 2025) —
Highmark Blue Cross Blue ShieldPittsburgh-based Blue plan for Pennsylvania, Delaware, West Virginia and New York, with Medicare, Medicaid and CHIP lines. Part of Highmark Health. Blue Cross Blue Shield companies Nearly 8 million across six states, including Blue KC (Highmark, 2026) 800-241-5704
EmblemHealthNonprofit New York City plan formed from GHI and HIP; sells individual, employer, Medicare and Medicaid plans and owns ConnectiCare in Connecticut. Regional and provider-owned plans — 888-225-6133
CDPHP (Capital District Physicians' Health Plan)Physician-founded plan in Latham, New York selling individual, employer, Medicare and Medicaid coverage; a merger with Excellus is planned for 2027. Regional and provider-owned plans — 888-258-0477

Listed by reach, then A to Z. This is a directory of the companies profiled on this site, not a list of every plan: a company that sells in a state may not sell in every county, and footprints change each plan year. Confirm with the marketplace, the state insurance department or the company.

Latest New York health insurance news