By state and plan type · New York

Medicare Advantage plans companies in New York

28 companies profiled on this site sell medicare advantage plans in New York. Private plans (Part C) that deliver Medicare benefits, usually with a network and often with drug coverage, including special needs plans for people with both Medicare and Medicaid.

Where to start in New York

Free Medicare counseling (SHIP)
HIICAP (Health Insurance Information, Counseling and Assistance Program), NYS Office for the Aging, 1-800-701-0501, https://aging.ny.gov/health-insurance-information-counseling-and-assistance-program-hiicap
Medigap rules in this state
Year-round guaranteed issue (continuous open enrollment) and community rating, per KFF; New York is one of only a few states (with Connecticut and Massachusetts) with continuous Medigap enrollment

Everything about health insurance in New York →

Companies that sell medicare advantage plans in New York

Company Type Size Member line
UnitedHealthcareLargest U.S. health insurer by medical members: employer, Medicare and Medicaid plans, plus ACA individual plans in 29 states for 2027. National health insurers 49.8 million medical members (UnitedHealthcare, end of 2025) —
Centene (Ambetter Health, Wellcare, Health Net)St. Louis-area insurer focused on government programs: Medicaid managed care, Ambetter marketplace plans, Wellcare Medicare plans and Health Net in California. National health insurers 25.7 million at-risk members, including 11.9 million Medicaid and 3.4 million marketplace (September 30, 2026) —
Aetna (CVS Health)CVS Health's insurance arm: employer, Medicare and Medicaid coverage; it left the ACA individual market after 2025. National health insurers 26.6 million medical members (year-end 2025) —
HumanaLouisville-based insurer centered on Medicare Advantage, with Part D, dental, vision, Medicaid and TRICARE contracts. It does not sell ACA marketplace plans. National health insurers About 7 million Medicare Advantage members, 20% of national Medicare Advantage enrollment (2026, KFF) —
Molina HealthcarePublicly traded, Medicaid-led insurer with smaller Medicare and marketplace lines; its marketplace footprint shrinks to about seven states for 2027. National health insurers About 4.4 million Medicaid, 222,000 Medicare and 267,000 marketplace members (third quarter 2026) —
HealthSpringMedicare plan brand of Health Care Service Corporation since 2025 (formerly Cigna Medicare): Medicare Advantage, Part D, Medigap and supplemental plans. Medicare Advantage and Medicare specialists About 700,985 Medicare Advantage members and 1.81 million stand-alone Part D members under the HealthSpring brand, plus 978,267 under Express Scripts Medicare (CMS, November 2026) 877-652-1739
WellcareCentene's Medicare brand: Medicare Advantage, special needs and stand-alone Part D plans. Tampa-founded insurer bought by Centene in 2020. Medicare Advantage and Medicare specialists Centene reported 954,400 Medicare Advantage-type members and 8,947,200 stand-alone Part D members across its Medicare brands (September 30, 2026) 844-657-2460
Devoted HealthMedicare Advantage-only insurer founded in 2017 by Todd and Ed Park; sells plans in 34 states and added more than 340 counties for 2027. Medicare Advantage and Medicare specialists More than 500,000 (Devoted website, 2026) 800-990-0723
Sun Life U.S.U.S. arm of Canadian insurer Sun Life Financial; sells employer dental and vision coverage and, through DentaQuest, runs Medicaid and CHIP dental programs. Dental and vision insurers About 32 million Americans with dental and vision benefits managed through Sun Life U.S. Dental, including DentaQuest (company figure, 2025) —
GEHA (Government Employees Health Association)Member association that runs nationwide fee-for-service plans, including a high-deductible option, for federal employees and retirees, plus FEDVIP dental. Federal employee and military plans — 800-821-6136
APWU Health PlanUnion-sponsored nationwide plan for federal employees and retirees: a fee-for-service High Option and a consumer-driven option; also offered to postal workers. Federal employee and military plans — 800-222-2798
MHBP (Mail Handlers Benefit Plan)Union-sponsored nationwide fee-for-service plan for federal employees and retirees, underwritten by an Aetna company; two options ended after 2026. Federal employee and military plans — 800-410-7778
SAMBA Health Benefit PlanNot-for-profit association running a nationwide fee-for-service plan with High and Standard options, open to all eligible federal employees and retirees. Federal employee and military plans — 800-638-6589
Foreign Service Benefit Plan (AFSPA)Worldwide fee-for-service plan run by AFSPA for Foreign Service staff and certain federal employees posted overseas; membership is limited to eligible groups. Federal employee and military plans — 202-833-4910
Compass Rose Health PlanNationwide FEHB plan from Compass Rose Benefits Group, open to all eligible federal employees since 2025; PPO and EPO options on the UnitedHealthcare network. Federal employee and military plans — 866-368-7227
Elevance Health (Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield, Wellpoint)Investor-owned insurer that holds Blue Cross and Blue Shield licenses in 14 states under Anthem names and sells Wellpoint plans elsewhere. National health insurers 45.2 million medical members (year-end 2025) —
Highmark Blue Cross Blue ShieldPittsburgh-based Blue plan for Pennsylvania, Delaware, West Virginia and New York, with Medicare, Medicaid and CHIP lines. Part of Highmark Health. Blue Cross Blue Shield companies Nearly 8 million across six states, including Blue KC (Highmark, 2026) 800-241-5704
Excellus BlueCross BlueShieldRochester-based nonprofit Blue plan covering 31 upstate New York counties with individual, employer, Medicare Advantage and state-program plans. Blue Cross Blue Shield companies Nearly 1.5 million members across the Lifetime Healthcare Companies (Excellus corporate overview, 2026) —
Empire BlueCross BlueShieldElevance Health's New York Blue plan, now shown as Anthem: individual, employer, Medicare and Medicaid coverage in eastern and southeastern New York. Blue Cross Blue Shield companies — —
MVP Health CareNot-for-profit upstate New York and Vermont plan selling individual, employer, Medicare and Medicaid coverage; affiliating with Independent Health. Regional and provider-owned plans Nearly 1 million combined with Independent Health if the affiliation is approved (MVP, 2026) 888-687-6277
Independent HealthWestern New York plan founded in 1980 as an HMO. Sells individual, state-sponsored, employer and Medicare plans; announced in 2025 it will join MVP Health Care. Regional and provider-owned plans About 325,000 members (company website, 2026) 800-958-4405
EmblemHealthNonprofit New York City plan formed from GHI and HIP; sells individual, employer, Medicare and Medicaid plans and owns ConnectiCare in Connecticut. Regional and provider-owned plans — 888-225-6133
HealthfirstHospital-sponsored nonprofit plan in the New York City area selling Medicaid, Essential Plan, marketplace and Medicare Advantage coverage. Regional and provider-owned plans more than 2 million New Yorkers (company, 2025) —
CDPHP (Capital District Physicians' Health Plan)Physician-founded plan in Latham, New York selling individual, employer, Medicare and Medicaid coverage; a merger with Excellus is planned for 2027. Regional and provider-owned plans — 888-258-0477
MediGoldNonprofit Medicare Advantage plans from Trinity Health in Ohio, Iowa, Michigan and New York, sold under several local names. Idaho plan ends for 2027. Medicare Advantage and Medicare specialists 99,515 Medicare Advantage members across Trinity Health plans, 64,485 of them in MediGold (CMS enrollment by contract, November 2026) 866-761-3348 (Trinity Health general Medicare line; TTY 711)
VNS HealthNonprofit New York plan group for people with Medicare and Medicaid: dual special needs plans, long-term care plans and a Medicaid plan for people with HIV. Medicare Advantage and Medicare specialists 74,845 Medicare Advantage members, November 2026 (CMS) 866-783-1444
Fidelis CareNew York plan owned by Centene: Medicaid, Child Health Plus, Essential Plan, marketplace plans (Ambetter from Fidelis Care) and Medicare plans. Medicaid managed care organizations More than 2 million members (company website, 2026) 888-343-3547
MetroPlus Health Plan (MetroPlusHealth)New York City health plan owned by NYC Health + Hospitals; Medicaid, Essential Plan, Child Health Plus, marketplace, Medicare Advantage and city employee plans. Medicaid managed care organizations Nearly 700,000 (company, 2026) 866-496-6636

Listed by reach, then A to Z. This is a directory of the companies profiled on this site, not a list of every plan: a company that sells in a state may not sell in every county, and footprints change each plan year. Confirm with the marketplace, the state insurance department or the company.

Latest New York health insurance news