Medigap and senior market carriers
Colonial Penn: plans, ratings and contacts
CNO Financial Group subsidiary best known for TV-marketed guaranteed-acceptance life insurance; it also sells Medicare Supplement (Medigap) plans.
Also known as Colonial Penn Life Insurance Company, Colonial Penn Medicare Supplement
Contact
| Member services | 877-877-8052 |
|---|---|
| Website | colonialpenn.com |
| Headquarters address | PO Box 1918, Carmel, IN 46082-1918 |
Company
| Legal name | Colonial Penn Life Insurance Company |
|---|---|
| Headquarters | Philadelphia, Pennsylvania |
| Ownership | Subsidiary of CNO Financial Group, a publicly traded holding company |
| Parent company | CNO Financial Group |
Where and what
| Where it sells | Medicare Supplement in every state except Massachusetts per a 2026 review; plans and states vary |
|---|---|
| Plan types | Medicare Supplement (Medigap), guaranteed-acceptance whole life insurance |
Fit
| Best suited to | People 50 and older who want to buy by phone or mail and are weighing a Medigap policy or small whole life policy without a provider network. |
|---|
Plans and products
- Medicare Supplement Plans A through N
- guaranteed-acceptance whole life
Brands and plan names
- Colonial Penn
- Bankers Life
- Washington National
Colonial Penn Life Insurance Company is a Philadelphia-based insurer owned by CNO Financial Group. Most people know it for television advertising of guaranteed-acceptance whole life insurance to people 50 and older, but it also sells Medicare Supplement (Medigap) policies, which is why it appears among senior-market insurers. This profile covers the company's structure, what it sells and where to check its current offerings.
Overview
Colonial Penn's home page focuses on guaranteed-acceptance whole life insurance for ages 50 to 85 in most states, and says it has specialized in simple, accessible life insurance since 1957. The page does not mention Medicare Supplement, but CNO's 2025 shareholder letter footer states that Medicare Supplement policies are sold by Colonial Penn Life Insurance Company. A 2026 third-party review says Medigap is sold through a partnership with Bankers Life and Casualty Company and Washington National Insurance Company, which are also CNO companies; the company's provider FAQ confirms that claims are handled through the Bankers name and that provider portals differ by the policy's underwriting company. Because the roles are described differently by different sources, the issuing company named in your policy documents is the one that matters.
History
Wikipedia says the company was founded in 1968 by Leonard Davis, a philanthropist and co-founder of AARP, and began as an insurance provider through AARP for people over 65. Colonial Penn's website gives an earlier start, saying it has operated since 1957. The sources do not agree, and neither is verified here against a regulator's record.
Ownership has changed several times, according to Wikipedia. FPL Group acquired the company in 1985, Leucadia National bought it in 1991, and Conseco bought it in 1997 and renamed it Conseco Direct Life in 1998. In 2001 the Colonial Penn name returned, and today the company sits alongside Bankers Life and Washington National within CNO Financial Group.
Plans and products
Two product lines matter here.
- Guaranteed-acceptance whole life: a small whole life policy for ages 50 to 85 with acceptance guaranteed, in most states. Ask whether the death benefit is reduced in the early policy years, and read the contract. This is life insurance, not health insurance.
- Medicare Supplement: a 2026 review lists Plans A, B, C, D, F, G, K, L, M and N, with Plan B only in Pennsylvania and Plans C and D only in New Jersey, and with high-deductible versions of Plans F and G. Plans C and F are limited to people who became eligible for Medicare before January 1, 2020. Plans vary by state; see Medigap explained: Medicare Supplement plans A through N.
Where it sells
The company's home page offers a state selector covering the states, the District of Columbia and the Virgin Islands. The 2026 review says Medigap policies are not available in Massachusetts and that availability otherwise depends on plan and state; the machine fields on this page list every state except Massachusetts for that reason. Your state's insurance department publishes the list of companies approved to sell Medigap there; see Pennsylvania for the home state's regulator.
Networks and how its plans work
A Medigap policy has no network. It pays its share of the Medicare-approved amount when you see a provider who accepts Original Medicare, for the plan letter you hold. A whole life policy pays a set death benefit and likewise has no network. See medigap for the standardized plans and how to compare health insurers: ratings, complaints and service for the questions to ask.
Ratings and reputation
I did not open a current AM Best or other agency rating for Colonial Penn, so none is stated; a third-party review reported an A- (Excellent) rating, but it did not give a date and could not be confirmed. AM Best's website carries current ratings. Consumer-facing reviews note that Colonial Penn does not offer online quotes for Medigap; you fill out a contact form and an agent calls or visits. The company is a frequent television advertiser; see how to spot a health insurance scam and what to do about it for how to read marketing claims and check a license. I did not open a primary source for any regulatory action or lawsuit, and none is asserted here; state insurance departments publish market conduct actions.
Costs and savings
No premiums are quoted here. Medigap prices depend on plan letter, age, state and rating method, and insurers can charge differently for the same lettered plan. Compare quotes from several insurers for the same letter, and consider the six-month open enrollment window; see medigap open enrollment period.
Enrolling and member service
Colonial Penn's Contact Us page lists a general line, 877-877-8052 (Monday to Thursday 8:30 a.m. to 10 p.m., Friday 8:30 a.m. to 7 p.m., Saturday 9 a.m. to 5 p.m., Eastern time), and a separate New York line, 877-891-0915. Mail goes to PO Box 1918, Carmel, Indiana; New York policyholders write to Bankers Conseco Life Insurance Company at the same box. Providers can use the self-service line 800-800-2254 for benefits and claim status. Complaints go to your state insurance department.
Who it suits
- Strengths: guaranteed-acceptance life coverage for ages 50 to 85, and a full range of lettered Medigap plans in many states.
- Weaknesses: no online Medigap quoting; benefit terms on guaranteed-acceptance life policies that need reading closely; the dividing line between Colonial Penn, Bankers Life and Washington National can confuse shoppers.
How to contact
| Service | Number or URL |
|---|---|
| General line | 877-877-8052 |
| New York residents | 877-891-0915 |
| Provider self-service line | 800-800-2254 |
| Website | https://www.colonialpenn.com |
Sources
- colonialpenn.com
- colonialpenn.com/contact-us
- en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colonial_Penn
- cno.mediaroom.com/CEO-Gary-C-Bhojwani-annual-shareholder-letter-2025
- seniorliving.org/insurance/medigap/colonial-penn/
- colpennproviders.bankers.com/web/colpenn/queandans
Facts were checked against these sources on the review date below. Plans, footprints, ratings and phone numbers change every year: confirm with the company, the marketplace or your state insurance department before you rely on them.
Profile last reviewed November 16, 2026