Install
By state and plan type · Wisconsin
Medigap (Medicare Supplement) insurers companies in Wisconsin
14 companies profiled on this site sell medigap policies in Wisconsin. Insurers that sell standardized Medigap policies that pay some of what Original Medicare does not.
Where to start in Wisconsin
-
- Free Medicare counseling (SHIP)
- State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP), 1-800-242-1060 (TTY 711), https://www.dhs.wisconsin.gov/benefit-specialists/medicare-counseling.htm
- Medigap rules in this state
- Wisconsin has a federal waiver for its own standardization: every insurer must offer a Basic Plan with up to seven optional riders (plus high-deductible variants similar to Plans K/L), not the lettered Plans A-N. Under-65 disabled enrollees get a six-month window but only the Basic Plan is required. 16 insurers (3 Medicare SELECT) sell Medigap in 2026.
Companies that sell medigap policies in Wisconsin
| Company | Type | Size | Member line |
|---|---|---|---|
| UnitedHealthcareLargest U.S. health insurer by medical members: employer, Medicare and Medicaid plans, plus ACA individual plans in 29 states for 2027. | National health insurers | 49.8 million medical members (UnitedHealthcare, end of 2025) | — |
| Aetna (CVS Health)CVS Health's insurance arm: employer, Medicare and Medicaid coverage; it left the ACA individual market after 2025. | National health insurers | 26.6 million medical members (year-end 2025) | — |
| HumanaLouisville-based insurer centered on Medicare Advantage, with Part D, dental, vision, Medicaid and TRICARE contracts. It does not sell ACA marketplace plans. | National health insurers | About 7 million Medicare Advantage members, 20% of national Medicare Advantage enrollment (2026, KFF) | — |
| AARP Medicare Supplement Insurance from UnitedHealthcareUnitedHealthcare's AARP-branded Medigap plans, sold under licence from AARP to AARP members; the largest Medigap program by enrollment. | Medigap and senior market carriers | 4.27 million Medigap members, 29.7% of the market (December 2025, Mark Farrah Associates) | — |
| Mutual of OmahaPolicyholder-owned Nebraska insurer best known for Medicare Supplement; also sells dental, hospital indemnity and other supplemental coverage. | Medigap and senior market carriers | About 1.3 million Medigap members, 9.4% of the market (December 2025, Mark Farrah Associates) | 800-775-6000 |
| Cigna Medicare Supplement (now HealthSpring)Cigna's Medicare Supplement (Medigap) policies belong to Health Care Service Corporation since March 2025 and are now sold under the HealthSpring name. | Medigap and senior market carriers | — | — |
| Physicians MutualOmaha-based mutual insurer selling Medicare Supplement (Medigap), dental and other senior-market coverage in about 30 states, mostly by phone and online. | Medigap and senior market carriers | — | — |
| Colonial PennCNO Financial Group subsidiary best known for TV-marketed guaranteed-acceptance life insurance; it also sells Medicare Supplement (Medigap) plans. | Medigap and senior market carriers | — | 877-877-8052 |
| United American Insurance Company (Globe Life)Globe Life subsidiary in McKinney, Texas that has sold Medicare Supplement (Medigap) since 1966, mainly through independent agents. | Medigap and senior market carriers | — | 800-331-2512 |
| Globe LifeMcKinney, Texas holding company whose subsidiaries sell life, supplemental health (cancer, accident, hospital) and Medicare Supplement policies through agents. | Short-term and supplemental carriers | — | 800-831-1200 |
| Elevance Health (Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield, Wellpoint)Investor-owned insurer that holds Blue Cross and Blue Shield licenses in 14 states under Anthem names and sells Wellpoint plans elsewhere. | National health insurers | 45.2 million medical members (year-end 2025) | — |
| HealthPartnersNonprofit Minnesota care system and health plan selling individual, employer, Medicare and Medical Assistance coverage in Minnesota and parts of Wisconsin. | Regional and provider-owned plans | 1.6 million medical and dental health plan members (company, 2026) | 800-883-2177 |
| QuartzWisconsin-based provider-owned health plan selling individual, employer, Medicare and Medicaid coverage in Wisconsin, Minnesota, northern Illinois and Iowa. | Regional and provider-owned plans | — | 800-362-3310 |
| Group Health Cooperative of South Central Wisconsin (GHC-SCW)Member-owned nonprofit HMO in the Madison, Wisconsin area that also runs its own clinics; sells individual, employer and Medicare Select coverage. | Regional and provider-owned plans | Over 70,000 (company site, 2026) | 608-828-4853 |
Listed by reach, then A to Z. This is a directory of the companies profiled on this site, not a list of every plan: a company that sells in a state may not sell in every county, and footprints change each plan year. Confirm with the marketplace, the state insurance department or the company.