Regional and provider-owned plans

AultCare: plans, ratings and contacts

Canton, Ohio health plan tied to the Aultman hospital system. It sells employer plans, Medicare Advantage and Medigap; it left ACA individual plans after 2025.

Also known as AultCare Insurance Company, AultCare Health Insuring Corporation, PrimeTime Health Plan, Aultman AultCare

Where it sellsStark County and surrounding northeast Ohio counties; the PrimeTime Medicare Advantage plan listed 11 counties in 2023
Member services800-344-8858

Contact

Member services 800-344-8858
Website aultcare.com
Headquarters address 2600 Sixth St. SW, Canton, OH 44710

Company

Headquarters Canton, Ohio
Ownership Nonprofit health plan within the Aultman family of organizations
Parent company Aultman Health Foundation

Where and what

Where it sells Stark County and surrounding northeast Ohio counties; the PrimeTime Medicare Advantage plan listed 11 counties in 2023
Plan types Employer group plans (including multiple employer welfare arrangements), Medicare Advantage (PrimeTime Health Plan), Medigap
Network types HMO, PPO, HMO-POS

Plans and products

  • Employer group plans
  • MEWA plans
  • Medicare Advantage
  • Medigap

Brands and plan names

  • PrimeTime Health Plan
  • PrimeTime Choices

AultCare is a health plan based in Canton, Ohio, that belongs to the Aultman group of hospitals and services. It sells employer plans, Medicare Advantage and Medicare supplement coverage, and it stopped selling ACA individual plans after 2025.

Overview

AultCare's website lists its product menu in two groups: group plans (employer plans and multiple employer welfare arrangements, or MEWAs, which let several small employers buy coverage together) and Medicare plans (Medicare Advantage and Medigap). Its address is 2600 Sixth St. SW in Canton, the same street as Aultman Hospital. The site says its commercial HMO and PPO plans carry NCQA accreditation.

The site names no parent, so the ownership link comes from other pages. Wikipedia's article on Aultman Hospital says the hospital runs a preferred provider organization called AultCare, and Aultman's own news page lists AultCare among the organizations in the Aultman family. Aultman Health Foundation is the nonprofit parent of that group.

By its own statements, AultCare handles claims for more than 430,000 people a year, works with over 50 in-network hospitals and more than 20,000 providers, and has operated for 40 years. These are company claims that this profile could not verify independently, and the site does not say whether the 430,000 figure includes people whose employers pay claims themselves and use AultCare only as an administrator.

Plans and products

  • Employer group. Employer plans and MEWA plans, per the company's site. The page does not break the line down by employer size.
  • Medicare Advantage. PrimeTime Health Plan is the Medicare Advantage HMO-POS plan that Aultman's October 2023 announcement describes, in a statement quoting AultCare's president. See Medicare Advantage explained: how Part C plans work.
  • Medigap. The site lists Medicare supplement plans. See Medigap explained: Medicare Supplement plans A through N and medigap.
  • ACA individual plans. No longer sold. InsuranceNewsNet reported on July 21, 2025 that AultCare would discontinue some plans, affecting about 6,000 enrollees; that article is behind a paywall, so this profile cannot say what it covered. healthinsurance.org's Ohio guide separately lists AultCare as having left the individual market at the end of 2025, so it is not an Ohio marketplace insurer for 2026 or 2027.

Where it sells

The AultCare name is concentrated in the Canton area (Stark County) and neighboring northeast Ohio. Aultman's 2023 announcement said the PrimeTime plan covered 11 counties: Carroll, Columbiana, Harrison, Holmes, Mahoning, Medina, Portage, Stark, Summit, Tuscarawas and Wayne. Plan service areas change yearly, so confirm the current list on Medicare.gov. For marketplace shoppers, see Ohio.

Networks and how its plans work

The commercial plans are HMO and PPO products. PrimeTime is an HMO with a point-of-service option (HMO-POS), which generally means in-network care plus limited out-of-network coverage under set rules. Aultman's announcement counted more than 50 hospitals and over 14,000 providers in the PrimeTime network. See Medicare Advantage.

Ratings and reputation

Aultman's October 2023 announcement said CMS gave PrimeTime Health Plan five stars out of five for the 2024 rating year, the third year in a row and the fourth time overall, and that CMS describes five stars as excellent. Star ratings are recalculated every year, and this profile did not find a current rating it could confirm, so the star field is empty. Medicare.gov's Plan Finder shows today's number. See medicare star ratings. No AM Best rating was found. Ohio insurance complaints go to the Ohio Department of Insurance, whose consumer line is 800-686-1526 according to healthinsurance.org.

Costs and savings

This profile does not quote premiums. Medicare Advantage premiums and out-of-pocket limits are set each year and appear in the Plan Finder. Employer plan costs are set by each employer.

Enrolling and member service

Employer coverage comes through an employer or a broker. Medicare plans are enrolled in through Medicare.gov, an agent, or the plan. Customer service runs weekdays from 7:30 a.m. to 5 p.m. Eastern, and the site invites walk-in help at the Canton address. Anyone who lost an AultCare individual plan after 2025 would have used HealthCare.gov; see what to do if your insurer leaves the marketplace in your area.

Who it suits

  • Strengths: a local plan tied to a regional hospital system, with employer and Medicare products and a Medicare Advantage plan that reached five stars in earlier years.
  • Weaknesses: it sells nothing on the individual marketplace, its footprint is regional, and its public pages give limited current rating and price detail.

How to contact

Service Number or URL
Member and general line 800-344-8858 or 330-363-6360 (TTY 711)
24-hour nurse line 866-422-9603 or 330-363-7620
Fraud, waste and abuse hotline 866-307-3528
Address 2600 Sixth St. SW, Canton, OH 44710
Website https://www.aultcare.com
State regulator Ohio Department of Insurance, 800-686-1526

Sources

  1. aultcare.com
  2. insurancenewsnet.com/oarticle/aultcare-to-discontinue-some-insurance-plans-affecting-abo…
  3. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AultCare
  4. aultman.org/news/october-2023/primetime-health-plan-scores-highest-rating-from-the-cente…
  5. healthinsurance.org/health-insurance-marketplaces/ohio/

Facts were checked against these sources on the review date below. Plans, footprints, ratings and phone numbers change every year: confirm with the company, the marketplace or your state insurance department before you rely on them.

Profile last reviewed November 16, 2026

Compare with similar companies

Terms to know

Related guides

Related states