Regional and provider-owned plans

Paramount Health (Paramount Insurance Company): plans, ratings and contacts

Toledo, Ohio insurer sold by ProMedica to Medical Mutual of Ohio in 2024. Sells Medicare Advantage, ACA, employer and short-term plans in Ohio and Michigan.

Also known as Paramount, Paramount Health Care, Paramount Elite Medicare Plans, Paramount Insurance Company

SizeMore than 77,000 health plan members and 308,000 dental plan members (January 2024 announcement)
Where it sellsOhio and Michigan primarily, according to the 2024 acquisition announcement; its own boilerplate said six Midwest states
Member services877-715-7044

Contact

Member services 877-715-7044
Website paramounthealthcare.com

Company

Headquarters Toledo, Ohio
Ownership Wholly owned subsidiary of Medical Mutual of Ohio (a nonprofit mutual) since 2024; previously owned by ProMedica
Parent company Medical Mutual of Ohio

Where and what

Where it sells Ohio and Michigan primarily, according to the 2024 acquisition announcement; its own boilerplate said six Midwest states
Plan types Medicare Advantage (Paramount Elite Medicare Plans), ACA individual plans, employer group plans, short-term plans
Network types HMO, PPO

Size

Members More than 77,000 health plan members and 308,000 dental plan members (January 2024 announcement)

Plans and products

  • Medicare Advantage
  • ACA marketplace plans
  • employer group plans
  • short-term plans

Brands and plan names

  • Paramount Elite Medicare Plans
  • Paramount Insurance Company

Paramount Health is a Toledo, Ohio health insurer that ProMedica, the Toledo hospital system, sold to Medical Mutual of Ohio in 2024. It sells Medicare Advantage, ACA individual, employer and short-term plans, mainly in Ohio and Michigan.

Overview

Paramount (legally Paramount Insurance Company, with Medicare plans sold as Paramount Elite Medicare Plans) was ProMedica's health maintenance organization. Wikipedia's article on ProMedica describes the system as including the HMO Paramount Health Care. Medical Mutual of Ohio, a Cleveland-area nonprofit mutual insurer, announced on January 29, 2024 that it would buy Paramount. At that point Paramount reported more than 77,000 health plan members and 308,000 dental plan members. Those are January 2024 figures, and this profile found no more recent count it could source.

This profile could not open Paramount's own website (the fetch failed on a certificate error), so it relies on Medical Mutual's pages, a Kaufman Hall transaction notice and healthinsurance.org. The company's site is the place to confirm current details.

History

The announcement said Paramount would become a wholly owned subsidiary of Medical Mutual and would keep offering its plans, with no immediate change for members, and expected the deal to close by May 1, 2024, pending regulatory approval. Kaufman Hall, which advised Medical Mutual, posted a notice dated June 10, 2024 saying Medical Mutual had acquired Paramount. This profile did not find a regulator or company page giving the exact closing date. Medical Mutual's Toledo pages now carry both companies' names, which is consistent with Paramount continuing as a brand.

Plans and products

  • Medicare Advantage. Paramount Elite Medicare Plans include HMO and PPO options, each under its own Medicare contract, according to Medical Mutual's Toledo page. See Medicare Advantage explained: how Part C plans work.
  • ACA individual plans. healthinsurance.org lists Paramount Insurance Company among Ohio marketplace insurers in 2026.
  • Employer group and short-term. Both were listed in the 2024 announcement and by Kaufman Hall. This profile did not find current product pages for them.
  • Dental. The 2024 announcement counted 308,000 dental members. This profile did not confirm whether the dental business is still part of Paramount.

Where it sells

The announcement said Paramount serves mostly Ohio and Michigan and described its footprint in boilerplate as individuals and employers across six Midwest states. Medical Mutual says it is "proud to welcome ProMedica" into its Medicare Advantage and individual ACA networks, so Medical Mutual's own plans reach the same Toledo health system. The Ohio state page, Ohio, covers the marketplace and who else sells there.

Networks and how its plans work

Paramount Elite Medicare Plans are HMO and PPO plans. In general an HMO limits coverage to a defined network except in emergencies, while a PPO pays something toward out-of-network care at a higher cost. See HMO and PPO. A plan's evidence of coverage, not a profile, defines the exact rules.

Ratings and reputation

This profile found no AM Best rating, NCQA rating or current CMS star rating it could source for Paramount, and the fields are empty. Medicare.gov's Plan Finder shows the star rating of each Medicare plan. Complaints go to the Ohio Department of Insurance, whose consumer line healthinsurance.org lists as 800-686-1526.

Costs and savings

This profile does not quote premiums. For 2027, healthinsurance.org reports that it found no Paramount individual-market rate filing in Ohio's SERFF system or on RateReview.HealthCare.gov. It says that does not confirm an exit, since Paramount's plans may be folded into Medical Mutual's, which is listed for 2027 under its legal name Medical Health Insuring Corp. with a proposed average increase of 21.6%. Anyone with a Paramount marketplace plan should check HealthCare.gov and their insurer's notices during open enrollment, and see what to do if your insurer leaves the marketplace in your area if a plan ends.

Enrolling and member service

Medicare plans can be enrolled in through Medicare.gov, a licensed agent or the plan. Marketplace plans come through HealthCare.gov. Employer plans come through an employer or broker.

Who it suits

  • Strengths: a plan with Toledo-area roots, now backed by a larger Ohio mutual insurer, with Medicare Advantage options in HMO and PPO form.
  • Weaknesses: its public footprint beyond Medicare Advantage is unclear for 2027, and its ownership change means plan names, networks and contacts may shift.

How to contact

Service Number or URL
Paramount licensed Medicare sales representative (listed on Medical Mutual's Toledo page) 877-715-7044 (TTY 711)
Medical Mutual of Ohio sales agent (same page) 800-543-3241 (TTY 711)
Ohio Department of Insurance consumer line (per healthinsurance.org) 800-686-1526
Medicare plan information https://www.medicare.gov/plan-compare

Sources

  1. medmutual.com/About-Medical-Mutual/Newsroom/2024/January/Medical-Mutual-Signs-Agreement-…
  2. kaufmanhall.com/news/medical-mutual-acquires-paramount-health
  3. medmutual.com/toledo
  4. medmutual.com/For-Medicare/Toledo
  5. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ProMedica
  6. healthinsurance.org/health-insurance-marketplaces/ohio/

Facts were checked against these sources on the review date below. Plans, footprints, ratings and phone numbers change every year: confirm with the company, the marketplace or your state insurance department before you rely on them.

Profile last reviewed November 16, 2026

Latest Paramount Health (Paramount Insurance Company) news

Compare with similar companies

Terms to know

Related guides

Related states