Medigap and senior market carriers
Everence: plans, ratings and contacts
Faith-based fraternal benefit society in Goshen, Indiana selling Medicare Supplement plans in 18 states, plus life, long-term care and financial services.
Also known as Everence Association, Everence Financial, Mennonite Mutual Aid, Everence Medicare Supplement
Contact
| Member services | 800-348-7468 |
|---|---|
| New members and sales | 888-236-0906 |
| Website | everence.com |
| Shop or enroll | everence.com/medsupp |
| Headquarters address | 1110 N. Main St., PO Box 483, Goshen, IN 46527 |
Company
| Legal name | Everence Association, Inc. |
|---|---|
| Headquarters | Goshen, Indiana |
| Founded | 1945 |
| Ownership | Fraternal benefit society (member-owned, nonprofit) |
Where and what
| Where it sells | Medicare Supplement in AZ, CA, CO, FL, IL, IN, IA, KS, MD, MI, MT, NE, OH, OK, OR, PA, SD and VA |
|---|---|
| Plan types | Medicare Supplement (Medigap), dental and vision for ages 60 and over, life insurance, disability, long-term care, annuities |
Size
| Members | More than 78,000 members, 2026 (Everence) |
|---|
Fit
| Best suited to | People on Original Medicare who want a Medigap policy from a faith-based, member-owned society and who are comfortable buying through its representatives. |
|---|
Plans and products
- Medicare Supplement Plans A
- G
- L and N
- Plan F for those first eligible before 2020
- dental and vision
- life insurance
- long-term care
- annuities
Brands and plan names
- Everence
- Everence Association
- Everence Federal Credit Union
Everence is the marketing name of Everence Association, Inc., a fraternal benefit society based in Goshen, Indiana. A fraternal benefit society is a member-owned nonprofit that offers insurance to its members as part of a shared mission, in this case an Anabaptist-rooted Christian one. Among its insurance lines, the one most relevant to this site is Medicare Supplement (Medigap), which it sells in 18 states.
Overview
Everence is a financial services organization as much as an insurer. Its website lists Medicare Supplement, Part D, life, disability and long-term care insurance, annuities, dental and vision plans for people 60 and older, investment management, charitable giving services and banking through Everence Federal Credit Union. It says it manages $8.9 billion in assets for clients who want their money aligned with their faith, and that it serves more than 78,000 members and over 35 denominations and church networks.
The Medigap policies are issued by Everence Association, Inc. at 1110 N. Main St., Goshen, Indiana. The company says its representatives are licensed insurance agents. The plans are not connected with or endorsed by the U.S. government or the federal Medicare program, as its disclosures state.
History
According to Everence, it began in 1945 as Mennonite Mutual Aid, created by Mennonite church leaders to extend mutual aid among church members, especially Anabaptist conscientious objectors returning from Civilian Public Service after World War II. The company says it became a nonprofit fraternal benefit society in 1966, and in 2010 it affiliated with Mennonite Financial Federal Credit Union, with both taking the name Everence. Its Medicare Supplement page adds that Everence began offering health insurance in 1965 and has sold Medicare Supplement plans since the mid-1980s.
Plans and products
The Indiana Medigap page lists Plans A, G, L and N. Plan F is available only to applicants who were first eligible for Medicare before 2020, because federal law stopped the sale of Plans C and F to people who became eligible on or after January 1, 2020. Plan A is offered to people under 65 who qualify for Medicare because of a disability in Maryland and Virginia, and in Colorado standardized plans are offered to people who qualify for Medicare because of a disability regardless of age, according to its Medicare Supplement page. Details vary by state, so each state page shows the plans, rating method and disclosures for that state.
All Medigap plans from every insurer cover the same benefits for a given letter, which is why Medigap explained: Medicare Supplement plans A through N treats price, rating method and service as the differences. Medigap works only with Original Medicare, not with Medicare Advantage; see Original Medicare vs Medicare Advantage: how to compare the two.
Where it sells
The state selector on the Medicare Supplement page lists Arizona, California, Colorado, Florida, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Maryland, Michigan, Montana, Nebraska, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, South Dakota and Virginia, and says the plans are not available in all states. The company's offices are listed in a smaller set of states, so the Medigap map and the local-office map are not the same. See Indiana and Pennsylvania for those states' regulators and Medicare help.
Networks and how its plans work
A Medigap policy has no network of its own. If a doctor or hospital accepts Original Medicare, the policy pays its share of the Medicare-approved amount under the plan letter you hold. The company's pages do not describe a provider directory for Medigap.
Ratings and reputation
I did not find a current AM Best, NCQA or CMS star rating for Everence Association in the pages I opened, so none is stated. No regulatory action or lawsuit was verified for this profile. State insurance departments publish complaint data and license status for Medigap insurers.
Costs and savings
Everence's pages do not publish premiums on the pages opened; it offers quotes through a form and says it responds within two business days. Medigap premiums depend on the plan letter, age, state and how the insurer rates policies (issue age, attained age or community rating), and the state disclosures explain which applies. Nothing here is a price. A fraternal society may also offer member benefits: the Indiana page mentions a wellness benefit and a will preparation benefit for members of Everence Association.
Enrolling and member service
Everence's pages do not state eligibility rules for buying a Medigap policy and do not say whether membership or a church connection is required in each state. Ask the company before applying whether any membership condition applies where you live. Federal rules give a six-month Medigap open enrollment period that starts when you are 65 or older and enrolled in Part B, during which insurers cannot use medical underwriting; see medigap open enrollment period. Outside it, many states let an insurer deny or charge more for a pre-existing condition.
You can reach the Indiana Medicare Supplement line at 888-236-0906 (Monday to Friday, 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. Eastern), or the main number at 800-348-7468. Complaints go to your state insurance department.
Who it suits
- Strengths: a long-standing nonprofit mutual-aid organization, standardized Medigap plans in 18 states, and local or national call-center representatives.
- Weaknesses: a smaller footprint than the national Medigap carriers, no online premium table in the pages opened, and an unclear membership requirement to confirm with the company.
How to contact
| Service | Number or URL |
|---|---|
| Main number | 800-348-7468 |
| Indiana Medicare Supplement line | 888-236-0906 |
| [email protected] | |
| Medicare Supplement | https://www.everence.com/medsupp |
Sources
- everence.com
- everence.com/medsupp
- everence.com/financial-services/insurance/medicare-supplement-insurance/medsupp-indiana
- everence.com/everence-articles/everyday-stewardship/your-stories/2020-summer-our-history…
Facts were checked against these sources on the review date below. Plans, footprints, ratings and phone numbers change every year: confirm with the company, the marketplace or your state insurance department before you rely on them.
Profile last reviewed November 16, 2026