Blog

Free help fighting a denial, by plan type: who to call

Which free helpers work on a denied claim for employer, marketplace, Medicare, Medicaid and government plans, what each can do, and what each cannot.

A denial letter reads as if you are on your own. You are not: for almost every kind of coverage there is a public agency, a counseling program or a nonprofit whose job includes helping people with exactly this problem, and most of them charge nothing. The catch is that the right helper depends on who runs your plan, and calling the wrong one costs days you may not have.

This post lines the helpers up by plan type, says what each one can and cannot do, and ends with a short decision list for choosing where to call first. Phone numbers and web addresses are left out on purpose, because they change; your denial notice, your plan card, your state insurance department's website and Medicare.gov list the current ones.

Start with one question: who regulates your plan?

Three facts about your coverage decide who can help:

  1. Who pays the claims. A plan can be fully insured (an insurance company bears the risk and is regulated by the state) or self-funded (an employer pays claims itself and hires an insurer or administrator to process them). Self-funded employer plans fall under federal law, not state insurance law. The terms are explained in self-funded plan, and Is my plan ERISA or state-regulated? Five clues and why it changes my appeal shows how to tell which one you have.
  2. Which program it belongs to. Employer, individual marketplace, Medicare, Medicaid and government employee plans each have their own appeal rules and their own referees.
  3. Whether the question is coverage or money. A denial of a service, a drug or a claim is an appeal. A billing mistake, a hospital charge or a collection call may need a different helper.

Your plan type is printed on your insurance card or in your plan documents. If it is not obvious, the plan's member services line can tell you whether it is fully insured or self-funded, and the answer is worth writing down.

The helpers at a glance

Your coverage Free helper What it can do What it cannot do
Fully insured employer or individual plan State insurance department (state insurance department) Takes complaints, checks the insurer followed state rules and deadlines, can press the insurer for an answer Rarely overturns a medical judgment itself; has no power over self-funded plans
Any private plan, in states that have one State consumer assistance program Explains rights, helps prepare appeals and external review requests, sometimes makes calls for you Not every state has one; capacity varies
Employer plan (including self-funded) U.S. Department of Labor benefits advisors Explain rights under federal law, contact the plan informally about a claim problem Cannot represent you or act as your lawyer; do not cover government plans
Marketplace plan Marketplace call center or navigator Help with enrollment, eligibility and the marketplace's own appeals; point you to the insurer's appeal A marketplace appeal is about eligibility and enrollment, not about whether a claim was covered
Original Medicare or Medicare Advantage SHIP counselor (SHIP), Medicare's help line, the Medicare quality improvement organization for fast appeals Explain notices, help file appeals, spot missed rights, help with discharge and service-ending appeals A SHIP counselor is not a lawyer and does not decide your case
Medicaid or CHIP State Medicaid agency, managed care ombudsman or enrollee help line, legal aid Explain the notice, help request a fair hearing, sometimes represent you at it Ombudsmen differ by state; they cannot order a plan to pay
Federal employee, military or other government plan The plan's own review process, then the agency that oversees it Review denials under that program's rules State insurance departments often have no authority here
Any plan, low income Legal aid office, law school clinic Legal advice and sometimes representation Limited hours and case types; may have waiting lists

The sections below add detail for each row.

Employer coverage

State insurance department. If your employer buys insurance from a company, the plan is fully insured and the state regulates the insurer. You can file a complaint, which starts a record and usually requires the insurer to respond in writing. The department checks whether the insurer followed the notice, timing and appeal rules, and some departments run or oversee the external review process. how to file a complaint with your state insurance department covers what to include. A department generally does not substitute its own medical opinion for the insurer's, so a complaint works best when you can point to a rule the insurer broke or a contract term it misread.

Department of Labor benefits advisors. Private-sector employer plans, including self-funded ones, are covered by a federal law called ERISA. The Department of Labor's Employee Benefits Security Administration has benefits advisors who answer questions about those rights, and who can sometimes contact a plan about a stalled claim. Government-employer plans and church plans are generally outside this, which is why government or school plan denial: where appeals go exists.

Your employer's benefits office. This is the helper people skip. A human resources benefits specialist can call the plan's escalation contact, and an employer that pays claims itself can sometimes ask its administrator to take a second look. Ask politely; the office is not obliged to intervene, and the plan's written appeal still has to be filed on time.

State consumer assistance programs. Some states fund a consumer assistance program that helps people with private coverage understand a denial, write an appeal and request an external review. Whether yours exists, and whether it serves employer plans or only individual ones, is something your state insurance department's website will say.

Marketplace coverage

An insurer's denial of a claim or prior authorization under a marketplace plan follows the same pattern as any fully insured plan: internal appeal, then external review. The helpers are the state insurance department and, where one exists, the state's consumer assistance program. The external review process may be run by the state or, in states without one, by the federal government; the denial letter says which. See external review explained: when an independent reviewer decides.

The marketplace itself, through HealthCare.gov or a state exchange, handles different disputes: whether you qualify for a subsidy, whether a special enrollment period applies, whether your coverage was ended. Navigators and certified enrollment counselors are free and can help with those. They are usually not the right door for a claim denial, although they can tell you which door is.

Medicare

SHIP counselors. Every state has a State Health Insurance Assistance Program, usually through the state's aging or insurance agency, with trained volunteers and staff. A counselor can read a Medicare Summary Notice or a Medicare Advantage denial with you, tell you which appeal level you are at and by when you must act, and help you complete the forms. The counselor does not argue your case or decide it.

Medicare's help line and the Medicare quality improvement organization. For some situations, such as a hospital discharge you think is too early or a skilled nursing or rehab stay the plan says is ending, the first call goes to the quality improvement organization named in the notice you were handed, within the short deadline the notice states.

Plan's own appeals unit. Medicare Advantage denials start with the plan's reconsideration, followed by an automatic independent review if the plan upholds the denial. Original Medicare appeals follow a separate set of levels. A SHIP counselor can say which applies to your notice.

Medicaid and CHIP

A Medicaid denial must come with written notice of your right to a fair hearing and how to ask for one. Where the plan is a managed care organization, you usually appeal to the plan first and then to the state (medicaid managed care explained: plans, networks and appeals). Helpers include:

  • The state Medicaid agency's enrollee help line. It can confirm the date on your notice and which deadline applies.
  • A managed care ombudsman or beneficiary support office, in states that have one. Its role differs by state; many will contact the plan for you.
  • Legal aid. Medicaid is the plan type where free legal help is most common, because legal aid offices see these cases regularly. Call early, before the hearing date is set.
  • Disease and disability organizations, many of which have staff who know how their state's Medicaid agency treats a given service.

medicaid cut my service: the notice, keeping benefits and the fair hearing covers the special case where a service you already receive is being reduced.

Government and school plans

Federal employee plans, TRICARE, retiree plans, and plans for state, county and school employees each have their own review processes, laid out in the plan's booklet. Appeals typically go to the plan first and then to the sponsoring agency or a designated reviewer, which is a different path from the state insurance department's. Ask the plan's member services line two questions: who hears the second-level appeal, and does anyone outside the plan hear a third. Many of these programs have a beneficiary counselor or an ombudsman role, and the booklet or the agency's website names the contact.

Hospital and provider-side help

When the fight is partly about a bill, a second set of free helpers exists on the provider's side:

  • The hospital's patient advocate or patient relations office, who can sometimes get a billing hold placed while an appeal runs.
  • The financial assistance office, which can reduce or write off a bill for patients under an income threshold; see hospital financial assistance and charity care: how to apply.
  • The doctor's office staff, who file prior authorizations and write the letters that win appeals.

None of these replaces the appeal. They buy time and add evidence.

Which helper first? A decision list

Use the first line that fits:

  1. A service is ending in days, or the patient is about to be discharged. Call the quality improvement organization or appeal contact in the notice immediately. Everything else can wait a day; this deadline may not.
  2. You have Medicare. Call your SHIP counselor, bring every notice, and ask which level you are on.
  3. You have Medicaid or CHIP. Call the number on the notice, confirm the hearing request deadline, then call legal aid the same day.
  4. You have an employer plan and do not know whether it is self-funded. Ask the plan, and ask your benefits office. If it is self-funded, the federal benefits advisors are your regulator; if it is fully insured, start with the state department.
  5. You have an individual or marketplace plan. Start with your state's consumer assistance program, if it has one, or the state insurance department.
  6. The denial involves a large amount, a life-altering treatment or a plan that follows ERISA. Add a consultation with a lawyer to whichever helper you chose; many offer an initial call, and Do I need a lawyer or a patient advocate for my denied claim? explains when that is worth it.
  7. Nothing above fits. Call your state insurance department. Even when it is not the right agency, it will usually say who is.

What to have ready when you call

Free helpers have limited time per caller, and the callers who get the most out of it show up organized. Have these in front of you:

  • the denial notice with its date, claim or reference number and the reason given;
  • your plan card, plan name and member ID, and whether the plan is employer, marketplace, Medicare or Medicaid;
  • every earlier notice on the same issue, in date order;
  • a one-paragraph summary: what was ordered or billed, who ordered it, why, and what you want reversed;
  • the deadline written on the notice, and the date you would like to file by;
  • a note of what you already did: calls, appeals, who you spoke with.

Ask each helper the same four questions: What deadline applies to me, and where is it written? Which level of appeal am I at? Is there a faster track because of my medical situation? Who else should I call? Write down each answer with the date and the person's name. The appeal and external review deadline calculator can turn a notice date into a calendar if you are not sure how to count.

Who each kind of help suits

  • An agency complaint suits someone who thinks the plan broke a rule, missed a deadline or ignored a document. It is slower than an appeal, and it does not stop an appeal clock.
  • A counselor or navigator suits someone who cannot tell what the notice is asking, or who has not yet filed. Counselors are strongest early.
  • Legal aid or a lawyer suits someone facing a hearing, a plan governed by federal benefits law, a very large bill or a treatment the plan has refused twice.
  • A provider's advocate or billing office suits someone with a bill in dispute, a collection letter or a care team willing to write supporting letters.
  • Your own appeal is always the main track. Helpers make it better; they do not replace it. how to appeal a denied health insurance claim, step by step covers the steps.

Key takeaways

  • The helper you need depends on who runs your plan, so find out first whether it is employer, marketplace, Medicare, Medicaid or a government plan, and whether an employer plan is self-funded.
  • State insurance departments cover fully insured plans, Labor Department advisors cover private employer plans, SHIP counselors cover Medicare, and Medicaid enrollees can reach the state agency, ombudsmen and legal aid.
  • A call to an agency or counselor does not pause the deadline on your denial notice; file the appeal while you seek help.
  • Free help works best when you arrive with the notice, a dated timeline and one clear question, and when you ask each helper to name the next one.
  • When money is the question as well as coverage, the hospital's patient advocate and financial assistance office are free, separate helpers worth adding.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic