Blog

How do I read the reason and remark codes on my denial letter?

Where reason and remark codes show up on an EOB, a denial notice and a provider remittance, what each family of codes means, and the first move for each.

A string such as "CO-50" or "PR-1" on an explanation of benefits looks like a secret language, but it is a small, standardized vocabulary that the insurance industry uses to explain every change between what a provider billed and what a plan paid. You do not need to memorize it. You need to know where the codes appear, which parts tell you who owes the money, which families of codes point to which first action, and how to confirm any code's meaning with the people who issued it.

Codes are shorthand. The denial letter's sentences and the plan's own documents decide your case, and the code meanings below are examples to recognize, not a substitute for asking. Confirm any specific code's meaning with the plan or the provider's billing office.

Where the codes appear

The same denial can show up in four places, and the codes differ in how visible they are.

  • Your explanation of benefits (EOB). The statement your plan sends after it processes a claim. Some plans print a code next to each line with a short message; others print only words such as "not covered" or "service not medically necessary." The guide How to read an explanation of benefits (EOB) line by line describes the layout. An EOB is not a bill.
  • The denial notice. If the plan denied all or part of a claim or a request, it sends a notice, which federal rules treat as an adverse benefit determination. It states the reason in words and, if you ask, gives you the code behind it (see below).
  • The provider's remittance advice. The plan sends the provider an electronic payment explanation line by line. That is where the standard reason and remark codes live in their raw form. The billing office can read it to you or print it.
  • A Medicare Summary Notice or plan notice, for Medicare. Original Medicare uses its own messages in the notice. Medicare Advantage plans send their own notices. The codes in this post are mostly from private-plan and Medicaid claims, but the idea is the same.

The three parts of a code line

On a remittance, each adjusted amount carries three pieces.

  1. A group code, which says who bears the money. The ones you will see most often: PR (patient responsibility: an amount the provider may collect from you), CO (contractual obligation: an amount the provider agreed to write off under its contract, which is generally not yours to pay), OA (other adjustment), PI (payer-initiated reduction) and CR (correction or reversal). Reading this part first is the fastest way to know whether a bill should reach you.
  2. A claim adjustment reason code, which says why. A number that stands for a standard reason, such as a deductible, a fee-schedule reduction or a denied service.
  3. Optional remark codes. Short codes that add detail the reason code cannot, often beginning with a letter such as M or N. A single line can carry more than one.

The reason and remark code lists are maintained centrally and updated several times a year, and plans may map their own internal reasons onto them. Two plans can describe the same problem with different codes, and the same code can sit on very different situations. Treat a code as a pointer to the family of problem.

Step 1: find the claim and the line

Match the denial to a single claim before you decode anything. Write down the claim number, the date of service, the provider name, the billed amount and the line or procedure the denial applies to. If you have a bill rather than an EOB, request the EOB from the plan. A line-by-line match with a tool such as Medical bill and EOB checker makes it easier to see which line is the denied one.

A claim can have several lines, and only one may be denied. A partial denial is common, and the paid lines need a different check from the denied one.

Step 2: read the group code

If the group code is CO, the amount is generally between the plan and the provider. The provider usually cannot bill you for a contractual adjustment, which is the case where the provider agreed to a rate. If the group code is PR, the amount is potentially yours, and the next step is to see which kind of patient responsibility it is. If you see OA or PI, ask the plan what they mean on your claim, since they cover many situations.

Step 3: place the reason in a family

Most reason codes fall into a handful of families. The table shows common examples of codes in each family and the first action each points to. The numbers are widely used examples, listed so you can recognize them. Confirm any code on your own paperwork.

Family What it generally says Example reason code First action
Patient responsibility Part of the allowed amount is the member's cost sharing: deductible, coinsurance or copay 1 (deductible), 2 (coinsurance), 3 (copay) Not a denial. Check the amounts against your plan terms and your running deductible total.
Contract or fee-schedule reduction The billed amount exceeds the contracted or allowed rate 45 Usually a write-off for an in-network provider. Confirm you are not being billed for it.
Not medically necessary The plan found the service did not meet its criteria 50 Ask for the written criteria and the clinical reviewer's rationale, then start the appeal route with your doctor.
Not covered The service is excluded or outside the benefit 96 Find the exclusion in the plan documents. Check that the service was coded accurately, since a wrong code can look like an exclusion.
Missing information or billing error The claim lacked data or had an error 16 Provider fix. Ask the billing office to correct and resubmit.
Duplicate The plan thinks it already processed this claim 18 Ask whether the first claim was paid. If so, this denial is harmless.
Bundled or included in another service The plan treats it as part of a different charge 97 Provider coding review, then a corrected claim or a provider appeal.
Authorization absent No prior authorization was on file 197 Ask whether authorization was obtained and recorded. See the post below on this situation.
Timely filing The claim reached the plan after the filing deadline 29 Ask the provider to document when it first filed.
Other coverage or coverage dates Another payer is primary, or coverage was not active on that date 22, 27 Check dates and other insurance, then supply corrected information.

Each row has a deeper story. A denial for lack of prior authorization can be repaired or overturned in several ways, covered in denied for no prior authorization: four situations and what each one allows. A claim turned away for late filing is covered in My claim was denied for filing too late: what can I still do?. A coding-related denial has its own walkthrough in my claim was denied for a coding error: who fixes it, me or the doctor?. The companion post What do the denial and remark codes on my EOB mean, and what do I do? goes deeper into the remark-code side.

Step 4: read the remark code

The remark code often says what the reason code does not. A reason code for "not covered" plus a remark code naming a specific limit, such as a frequency or an age limit, tells you the service is covered in principle but you reached the limit. A reason code for a missing-information denial plus a remark code naming the missing item tells the billing office exactly what to supply. If you cannot find a remark code's meaning in the EOB, ask the plan to send the full text of every remark code on the claim.

Step 5: confirm the meaning in writing

You do not have to guess. For plans covered by the federal appeal rules, which include most non-grandfathered individual and employer plans, you can ask the plan to provide the diagnosis code and procedure code on the claim, what each of them means, and the denial code and its meaning, and the plan should provide them. A short, written request works: "Please send me the denial code and its meaning for claim [number], and the diagnosis and treatment codes with their meanings."

That request is useful for another reason. The denial notice is also supposed to state the specific reason in understandable words, identify the plan provision relied on, and describe how to appeal. If the notice is vague, the codes may be the only specific information you have. The checklist in What must my health plan's denial letter include? A checklist to hold it against shows what a compliant notice contains.

A worked example, with invented numbers

Say Luis, a hypothetical member, gets an EOB with two lines for a visit on March 3.

  • Line 1, office visit. Billed $250, allowed $120, plan paid $90, and a patient responsibility of $30 with group code PR and reason code 3 (a copay). The remaining $130 is group code CO with reason code 45 (above the contracted rate). Reading it: Luis owes $30. The $130 is a write-off under the provider's contract. Total: $120 allowed = $90 plan + $30 Luis; $250 billed = $120 allowed + $130 write-off. Nothing to dispute.
  • Line 2, a lab test. Billed $400, allowed $0, plan paid $0, group code CO, reason code 50, and a remark code that the plan's own EOB describes as "medical necessity criteria not met." Reading it: the plan denied the test as not medically necessary, and because the group code is CO, the provider is not generally allowed to bill Luis if it is an in-network provider that agreed to the plan's terms. In many plans the member is protected from the bill in this case unless the member agreed in advance, in writing, to pay for a service the plan would not cover. That depends on the contract, so Luis does not assume.

Luis's first action: he calls the provider's billing office and asks, "Is the $400 being billed to me, or written off?" If the office says it is his, he asks for a copy of the remittance and for the plan's medical-necessity criteria for that test. Then he asks his doctor's office whether it wants to request a review, since the ordering doctor knows why the test was ordered. The denial then follows the route in how to appeal a denied health insurance claim, step by step, and the clock for the appeal runs from the date on the denial notice, as described in appeal and external review deadlines: how many days you have.

What to say on the call

At the plan: "I am calling about claim [number] dated [date]. The explanation of benefits shows reason code [code] and remark code [code]. Please explain in plain words what they mean, which plan provision applies, and what information would change the decision. Please also tell me the date the appeal period for this claim ends."

At the provider: "The remittance for this claim shows group code [code] and reason code [code]. Is this amount being billed to me? If it is a billing error, can you submit a corrected claim and tell me the date?"

Write down the representative's name and the date, and ask for a reference number.

When the codes and the letter disagree

Sometimes the remittance and the notice use different language. Treat the written denial notice as the plan's stated position, and the codes as supporting detail. If they conflict, tell the plan and ask it to clarify in writing, since the explanation of the reason is what you will cite on appeal. If the notice states no usable reason, request a full copy of the claim file and the plan's rules for the decision. An appeal deadline does not pause because the notice was unclear, so calendar it from the notice date while you ask.

Free help with the codes comes from a state consumer assistance program, a patient advocate, a hospital financial counselor or the state insurance department's consumer line. A health care billing advocate can also read a remittance, although some charge fees.

Key takeaways

  • Reason and remark codes appear on the provider's remittance, often on your EOB and, on request, behind a denial notice.
  • Read the group code first: CO usually means a provider write-off, PR means an amount that may be yours.
  • Most reason codes fall into families such as patient responsibility, medical necessity, not covered, missing information, duplicate, authorization and timely filing, and each points to a different first action.
  • Confirm any code's meaning with the plan or the billing office, in writing if possible, since lists change and plans map their own reasons to them.
  • A code never replaces the denial notice. The notice, the plan documents and your appeal deadline decide what happens next.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic