Blog

Make a doctor and hospital list before you compare plans (worksheet)

A fill-in table for every doctor, hospital and pharmacy your household uses, a score card for each candidate plan, and a worked example for a family of three.

Most people compare plans by premium, deductible and the list of covered services, and then discover in February that their pediatrician is not in the network. A list of the doctors and hospitals your household actually uses, made before you open a single plan page, reverses the order: you ask which plans fit your care instead of asking which care fits a plan. The list takes about half an hour and can be reused every year.

This worksheet has three parts: the list itself, a score card that records what you learn about each plan, and a visit-weighted tally that shows which plans cover most of what you really use. A worked example for a household of three follows, with every number invented for illustration.

Part 1: The list

Make one row for every person and every provider they see, including the ones you see rarely. Copy this table into a document or spreadsheet.

Person Provider name Specialty Practice and address Hospital affiliation Visits per year Must keep? Notes

Fill each column this way:

  • Person: who sees this provider.
  • Provider name and specialty: write the name as it appears on a bill or statement, since a directory search for the name as you say it may not match.
  • Practice and address: many doctors work at several locations, and a plan may include some and not others.
  • Hospital affiliation: ask the office where the doctor operates or admits patients. The hospital is its own line on the plan's network and has to be checked separately.
  • Visits per year: count last year's visits from your explanation of benefits statements or appointment history, and add what you already know is coming (a procedure, a pregnancy, physical therapy).
  • Must keep: write yes if leaving this provider would harm your care, for instance a surgeon in the middle of a treatment plan, and no if you would be willing to change.
  • Notes: referral required, telehealth only, accepting new patients, anything the office told you.

The other lines to add

Below the provider rows, add:

  1. Hospitals you would use for planned care and the one nearest for emergencies. Include the children's hospital if you have a child.
  2. Pharmacy: the store you use, the mail-order service if any, and whether any prescription is a specialty drug.
  3. Labs and imaging centers your doctors send you to. These are often separate businesses, and a plan may treat them differently from the doctors who order the tests.
  4. Therapy and mental health providers, including physical therapists, since their visit counts are often high.
  5. Equipment suppliers if you use any, such as a CPAP provider or a diabetes supply company.

For the medications themselves, the doctor, hospital and drug network check worksheet on this site includes a table for drug names, strengths and the plan's formulary information, and How do I check my prescriptions on a plan's formulary before I enroll? shows how to look each one up.

Part 2: The score card

Pick the plans you are considering, no more than four at first. For each provider on your list, you will mark each plan with one of three codes:

  • In: confirmed in network for this specific plan and network, by the practice's billing office or the plan, not only the directory.
  • Out: the practice or plan says it is not in the network.
  • ?: unconfirmed. The directory says yes, or you have not asked.

Copy this table and add a column for each plan:

Provider or place Visits per year Plan A Plan B Plan C Plan D

Mark ? first, from the directory, and replace each ? with In or Out as you confirm it. A directory result is a starting point only; The directory lists my doctor as in network. How do I confirm before I enroll? has the order of steps and a call script. Keep a separate note of who you spoke to and when.

At the bottom of each plan's column, add three lines:

  1. Must-keeps that are Out. If this number is above zero, ask whether the plan has an exception process before taking the plan any further.
  2. Visits In, Out and ?. Add the visits-per-year numbers for each code.
  3. Share of visits confirmed In. In visits divided by all visits, written as a percentage.

The percentage is a screen, not a verdict. It treats a physical therapist you see eight times a year the same as a pediatrician you see eight times a year, and it ignores cost and quality. Its purpose is to flag plans that fit poorly with how you use care.

A worked example for a household of three

Say Priya, 41, her husband Marcus, 43, and their son Jonah, 9, are comparing three plans. All names and numbers are invented.

The list (Part 1):

Person Provider Specialty Practice Hospital Visits per year Must keep?
Priya Dr. Okafor Family medicine Eastside Family Practice Riverside Medical Center 2 No
Priya Dr. Lindgren Endocrinology Lindgren Endocrine Clinic Riverside Medical Center 3 Yes
Marcus Dr. Reyes Family medicine Eastside Family Practice Riverside Medical Center 1 No
Marcus Hollis Physical Therapy Physical therapy Hollis clinic, Main Street None 8 No
Jonah Dr. Hale Pediatrics Hale Children's Care Riverside Medical Center 4 Yes
Jonah Dr. Park Allergy Park Allergy Associates None 3 No

That is 2 + 3 + 1 + 8 + 4 + 3 = 21 visits a year. They add one hospital line, Riverside Medical Center, which they want for any planned care, and one pharmacy, Main Street Pharmacy, where Priya fills a monthly generic for her thyroid condition.

The score card (Part 2), after the family confirms what they can:

Provider or place Visits Plan A Plan B Plan C
Dr. Okafor 2 In In In
Dr. Lindgren 3 In Out In
Dr. Reyes 1 In In In
Hollis Physical Therapy 8 Out In In
Dr. Hale 4 In In ?
Dr. Park 3 ? Out In
Riverside Medical Center n/a In In Out

The tally:

  • Plan A: In visits are Okafor 2 + Lindgren 3 + Reyes 1 + Hale 4 = 10. Out is Hollis, 8. Unknown is Park, 3. Share confirmed in: 10 ÷ 21 = 47.6%. If Park turns out in network, 13 ÷ 21 = 61.9%. Must-keeps Out: none (Lindgren and Hale are both In).
  • Plan B: In visits are Okafor 2 + Reyes 1 + Hollis 8 + Hale 4 = 15. Out are Lindgren 3 and Park 3, a total of 6. Share In: 15 ÷ 21 = 71.4%. Must-keeps Out: one, Dr. Lindgren.
  • Plan C: In visits are Okafor 2 + Lindgren 3 + Reyes 1 + Hollis 8 + Park 3 = 17. Unknown is Hale, 4. Share confirmed In: 17 ÷ 21 = 81.0%, and 100% if Hale is confirmed. But Riverside Medical Center is Out, and Dr. Hale, a must-keep, is unconfirmed.

What the family learns from the card:

  • Plan B has a higher share than Plan A but loses a must-keep, Dr. Lindgren, so the percentage alone misleads.
  • Plan C looks best on visits but excludes the hospital they want for planned care, and one must-keep is unknown. They have two questions to settle before Plan C is a real contender: whether Dr. Hale is in, and whether the missing hospital matters for the care they expect, which is a question for Dr. Hale and Dr. Lindgren's offices about where they would send the family.
  • Plan A is the only one with no Out must-keeps and an In hospital, but 8 visits of physical therapy at Hollis are Out. Marcus can ask the plan for a network exception or look for another in-network therapist, and the family can price the out-of-network visits.

The score card did not choose a plan, and it should not. It showed which three phone calls matter most: Hale on Plan C, Park on Plan A, and the physical therapy question on Plan A. After those calls, the family can bring real numbers into the cost comparison in how to compare health plans: premium, deductible, network and drugs.

What first drafts of the list usually leave out

When people fill in the list the first time, a few entries are missing, and each one can change a plan's fit:

  • The doctor who is not on your mind. A dermatologist you see once a year, an eye doctor, a dentist if the plan includes dental. Add them with one visit each.
  • The doctor behind the doctor. The surgeon is on your list, but the anesthesia group, radiologist and pathologist at the hospital may contract separately. You cannot list them all in advance, but you can add a line reminding you to ask, as why might my anesthesiologist be out of network at an in-network hospital? explains.
  • Tests and procedures you expect. If a doctor has told you to expect a colonoscopy, an MRI or a surgery next year, write the facility and the likely cost, and ask whether the procedure needs prior approval.
  • Telehealth. If you rely on video visits with a particular practice, check whether the plan covers telehealth with that practice, or uses its own telehealth vendor.
  • A provider you are thinking of leaving. If you want to change doctors anyway, note it. A plan with a better choice of in-network doctors in that specialty may beat one with your current doctor.

You can also add a column for what each visit costs you under the plan, once you have the plan's copays and coinsurance. That turns the visits-per-year column into a rough yearly estimate for in-network care, and the health plan comparison calculator on this site can do the arithmetic for several plans at once. Keep the estimate separate from the network check: a plan that is cheaper per visit helps only if your providers are in it.

Part 3: Turn the card into a short list of questions

For each plan still in the running, write down the open questions and who will answer them:

  1. Every ? goes to the practice's billing office and the plan, with the plan's exact name. The call script in The directory lists my doctor as in network. How do I confirm before I enroll? works.
  2. Every Out must-keep goes to the plan as a question about exceptions and continuing care, and to the provider as a question about whether they are pursuing a contract.
  3. The hospital line goes to the doctors' offices: where would you send me for surgery, and is that hospital in this plan?
  4. Referral and authorization rules. For HMO and similar plans, ask whether your specialists need a referral from a primary care physician.

Keeping the list up to date

Keep the list in one place and update it after each visit or change: a new provider, a move, a retirement, a new prescription. Next year's open enrollment then starts from a current record, and the visits-per-year column will be accurate. Add a line at the top with the date of the last review.

If you are choosing a marketplace plan, a navigator can help you use the list in the shopping tools without any charge. For employer plans, the benefits office can often confirm network names. questions to ask before you enroll: doctors, hospitals and drugs covers the questions you might add for doctors, hospitals and drugs, and open enrollment checklist places this worksheet in the larger sequence of enrollment tasks.

Key takeaways

  • Build the list first: every person, provider, hospital, pharmacy and lab, with the visits per year and a must-keep flag.
  • Mark each provider In, Out or ? for each plan, and move a ? to In or Out only after the billing office or the plan confirms it.
  • A visits-weighted percentage shows fit, but a single Out must-keep can matter more than a high percentage.
  • In the example, the three plans score 47.6%, 71.4% and 81.0% confirmed In, and each has a different open question that decides it.
  • Keep the worksheet and update it each year, since the visits column and the providers change.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic