Blog
How do I check my prescriptions on a plan's formulary before I enroll?
Walk through three regular medications: find the formulary, read tiers and restriction codes, check pharmacies and handle an out-of-date PDF.
Say Dana, 52, is buying her own coverage for next year and takes three medications every month: a brand-name drug for a chronic condition, a generic for blood pressure and a generic for cholesterol. She has spent an evening on plan comparison pages that list premiums and deductibles and say almost nothing about drugs. What she needs is the plan's formulary, the list of drugs the plan covers, and the knack of reading it.
The steps below follow Dana from the first search to a confirmed answer. They apply to marketplace plans and employer plans alike, though the places to look differ. Rules about what plans may change during the year vary, so this walkthrough concentrates on what to confirm now, while you can still pick a different plan.
Step 1: Write down each drug exactly
A formulary is searched by drug name, and a small difference can send you to the wrong line. For every medication write:
- The name, noting whether it is the brand or the generic.
- The strength, such as 10 mg, and the form: tablet, capsule, inhaler, injection, extended-release.
- The quantity and frequency your prescription says, for instance 30 tablets a month or 90 tablets every 90 days.
- The pharmacy you use, and whether you want mail order.
- Whether your doctor can substitute a different drug if needed. Ask the doctor which alternatives would be acceptable, in case the first choice is not covered.
Use the label on the bottle or the pharmacy printout. The doctor, hospital and drug network check worksheet has a table for this information, along with the doctors and hospitals you want to check.
Step 2: Find the formulary for the specific plan
Plans sold by the same insurer can use different formularies, so the drug list for one plan does not tell you about another. Look for the one that matches the plan name you are considering.
- Marketplace plans. The plan details page on the marketplace, or the insurer's own page for the plan, usually links to the formulary under a heading such as drug list, prescription coverage or formulary. Many marketplace shopping tools let you enter your drugs and show which plans cover them. Treat the tool's result as a first screen and confirm it against the formulary itself.
- Employer plans. The benefits portal or the insurer's member site has the formulary, and the benefits office can name the right version. Ask for the version for the plan year you are choosing for.
- Medicare plans. Part D and Medicare Advantage plans publish formularies, and Medicare.gov's plan finder lets you enter drugs. Medicare has its own rules, so use How to compare Part D plans: formulary, pharmacies and total cost for those.
If a plan has more than one formulary and you cannot tell which applies, call and ask the representative to name it. Write down the date.
Step 3: Search the drug and read the line
A formulary entry commonly shows the drug name, a tier and a code or two. Here is what Dana finds for her three medications in a hypothetical plan. The drug names and results are invented.
| Drug | Tier | Notes on the formulary |
|---|---|---|
| Blood pressure generic, 10 mg tablet | 1 | |
| Cholesterol generic, 20 mg tablet | 1 | QL |
| Brand-name drug for her condition, 50 mg tablet | 3 | PA, ST |
Each part tells her something:
Tier. A formulary tier is the level at which the plan places a drug, and the tier determines what you pay. Tiers are numbered from lower to higher cost, with generics usually at the bottom and brand names and specialty drugs above. Plans differ in how many tiers they use and what each costs, so the tier number matters only after you look up what that tier costs in this plan. The summary of benefits and coverage lists it, as a flat copay or a percentage. Two plans, same premium, different drug tiers. Which one costs me less? works through how two plans with the same premium can cost different amounts for the same drugs.
A tier is not a price. The same drug can sit on a different tier in two plans. A generic can also be on a higher tier than you would expect; Why is my cheap generic drug on a higher tier than I expected? covers why.
Restriction codes. The notes column holds the rules that apply before the plan pays:
- QL, a quantity limit. The plan pays for only a set amount in a period, for example 30 tablets in 30 days. If your prescription is for a higher dose or number than the limit allows, the plan may refuse part of it. See quantity limit.
- PA, prior authorization. Your doctor must send the plan information showing that the drug is medically necessary before it pays. how prior authorization works and what to do when it is denied explains the process, and the post what my doctor has to send for a drug prior authorization to succeed covers what a drug request includes.
- ST, step therapy. The plan expects you to try one or more other drugs first, and pays for the one you want only if those fail or are unsuitable. step therapy explained: "fail first" rules and how to get an exception covers how to ask for an exception.
- SP or LD, and similar. Some formularies mark specialty drugs, which may need to come from a particular specialty pharmacy, and limited-distribution drugs. Others mark drugs not covered at all, sometimes with the letters NF.
Codes and abbreviations vary by insurer. Every formulary has a key explaining its own, usually on the first or last page.
What Dana learns
Her two generics are on Tier 1, which is the least expensive tier in most plans. The cholesterol generic has a quantity limit, so she checks whether her prescription fits: it is for 30 tablets a month, which equals the limit. The brand-name drug is on Tier 3 with prior authorization and step therapy. Her doctor must submit paperwork and, depending on the plan's step requirement, she may need to show she has already tried a cheaper drug. She already took the earlier drug years ago, and her records show it. That is a question to put to her doctor's office now, before enrolling, because it decides whether the plan is workable.
Step 4: Check what the tier costs and whether a drug deductible applies
Finding the drug on the formulary tells you the plan covers it. It does not tell you what you pay. Open the summary of benefits and coverage and find the section for prescription drugs. Look for:
- The cost for each tier: a flat copay such as $10, or coinsurance such as 30% of the plan's price.
- Whether a drug deductible applies and to which tiers. Some plans apply the medical deductible to all drugs, some to brand and specialty tiers only and some have none.
- The out-of-pocket maximum and whether drug costs count toward it. In most plans covered by the ACA's rules they do, but check.
- Different cost for a 30-day supply compared with 90 days by mail order.
what my medications will really cost over a full year by tier gives a way to turn these into a yearly figure. A short illustration: say a tier 3 brand drug costs the plan $400 a fill, and the plan has a $200 drug deductible followed by 30% coinsurance. Her first fill costs $200 + 30% × $200 = $260. Later fills are 30% × $400 = $120. Over twelve fills she pays $260 + 11 × $120 = $1,580. A different plan with a flat $60 copay and no deductible would cost $720 a year for the same drug. The premium is the other part of the comparison, and a lower premium can still lose if the drug costs more.
Step 5: Check the pharmacy network
A covered drug at the wrong pharmacy can cost more. Look for:
- Whether your pharmacy is in the plan's network. A plan may have a broad network and a narrower group of preferred pharmacies with lower copays.
- Whether the plan requires mail order for maintenance drugs after a few fills. A mail-order pharmacy can lower the cost of a 90-day supply, and some people prefer to pick up locally.
- Whether specialty drugs must be filled at a designated specialty pharmacy. If so, the plan's list tells you which one.
Ask the pharmacy too. A pharmacist will usually say which plans it is in network for, and some can check a drug's coverage under a plan if you give them the plan name.
Step 6: What to do when the formulary PDF is out of date
Formularies are published as documents, and they are changed through the year. The one you find may predate the current list, or the plan may update it after you enroll. To protect yourself:
- Note the date on the document. If it has none, say so when you call.
- Call the plan and ask the representative to look up each drug, by name, strength and form, against the current formulary for the plan year you are choosing. Ask whether any change is planned that would take effect at the start of the plan year.
- Ask for confirmation in writing, by email or chat transcript, and keep it with the date and the representative's name.
- Ask about a transition fill. Some plans let new members fill a drug that is not on the formulary for a short time while the member and doctor arrange a switch or an exception. Whether yours does is a question for the plan.
- Know the exception route. If a drug you need is not covered, a formulary exception request, with your doctor's statement, asks the plan to cover it anyway. what to do when your plan will not cover a drug you need shows how, and my plan dropped my medication from its formulary: what are my options? covers what happens when a drug leaves the formulary during the year.
Plans can usually change a formulary during a plan year, with notice to members, and the rules for how much notice and what protection a member has vary by plan type and state. The plan's member handbook or the state insurance department can say what applies to you.
Step 7: Keep a record and decide
For each plan, record for each drug the tier, any codes, the cost at that tier, the pharmacy result and the date you checked. A simple table works:
| Plan | Drug | Covered? | Tier | Codes | What I pay per fill | Pharmacy in network? | Date checked |
|---|
If a drug is not covered, or carries restrictions you cannot meet, treat that as a cost. If the brand-name drug would cost $1,580 a year on one plan and $720 on another, that gap can outweigh a difference in premiums. If you are unsure how to read a plan, a marketplace navigator can go through the formulary with you at no charge, and for an employer plan the insurer's member line can do it.
Key takeaways
- Write down each drug's exact name, strength, form and quantity, and search each plan's own formulary, since two plans from one insurer may differ.
- A tier is not a price; read the summary of benefits to see what the tier costs and whether a drug deductible applies.
- Prior authorization, step therapy and quantity limits are decided before the plan pays, so ask your doctor's office now whether you meet them.
- Confirm the pharmacy network, and ask the plan to check each drug against its current list in writing if the PDF is old.
- If a drug you need is not covered, a formulary exception request is the path, and a drug you cannot get covered counts as a cost of the plan.