Blog

How do insurers pick the level of eating disorder care they will pay for?

How plans choose among the levels of eating disorder care, why weight alone misleads, what records matter and how to appeal a step-down.

A common version of this story: a treatment team recommends partial hospitalization for a patient with an eating disorder, and the plan approves only an intensive outpatient program, or approves a residential stay and then says after two weeks that the patient can step down. Families hear the decision as a verdict on how sick the patient is. It is better understood as the result of a checklist the plan applies, using information the plan received, at a particular moment. Knowing what is on the checklist, and what information reaches it, is most of the work of challenging a decision.

This post explains the levels of care, how plans decide among them, why weight is a weak basis for the decision, what a treatment team documents and how to appeal a step-down. It does not give clinical advice; the treatment team decides what a patient needs, and the plan decides what it will pay for.

The levels of care

Treatment for eating disorders is arranged in steps. Plans and programs name them differently, so ask the plan what it calls each. The usual ladder, from least to most intensive, looks like this.

Level What it usually involves Typical setting
Outpatient Weekly or less frequent visits with a therapist, a dietitian and a medical clinician Offices, telehealth
Intensive outpatient Several hours a day on a few days a week, often including supervised meals Program or clinic; patient lives at home
Partial hospitalization Most of the day on most days of the week, with supervised meals and medical monitoring Hospital or program; patient lives at home or nearby
Residential Round-the-clock care in a living setting, with therapy and meal support Residential facility
Inpatient hospitalization Medical stabilization with monitoring of heart rate, blood pressure, labs and nutrition Hospital

Plans review each level separately and give separate approvals for each, which is why a patient can be approved for one level and have the next level denied or cut short.

How the plan decides: utilization review

The process that produces the decision is called utilization management. A reviewer at the plan, or at a company the plan hires, compares the clinical information the program sends against written criteria and decides whether a level of care is medically necessary. The first review happens at the request for authorization, as explained in how prior authorization works and what to do when it is denied. Further reviews happen during treatment, called concurrent reviews, typically every few days to every few weeks depending on the level of care. The program sends updates, and the plan either approves more days or says the patient can move to a lower level.

The criteria come from one of three sources. Some plans use criteria published by professional or specialist organizations. Some buy a proprietary set of guidelines from a vendor. Some use the plan's own policy, written in house. They differ in detail, but they tend to ask about the same categories of facts:

  • Medical stability. Heart rate, blood pressure, temperature, laboratory results such as electrolytes, and other findings that show whether the body is at risk. This is the main reason someone is moved to a higher level of care.
  • Weight and the pace of change. Weight relative to expected weight, and how fast it is falling or rising.
  • Eating and behavior. Whether the patient can complete meals, how often there is restriction, bingeing, purging or compensatory exercise, and whether those behaviors are getting better or worse.
  • Mental health and safety. Co-occurring conditions, thoughts of self-harm, and the ability to participate in treatment.
  • Motivation and engagement. Whether the patient is willing and able to take part.
  • Response to earlier care. What lower levels were tried and what happened.
  • The home and support environment. Whether the home supports recovery or whether a safe, structured setting is needed.

Reviewers commonly apply these in order: can the patient be treated safely at a lower level? A step up is approved when the answer is no, and a step down is made when the answer becomes yes.

Why weight alone is a poor measure

Many families are told, in effect, that the patient's weight is too high or too normal for the level of care requested. Plans that lean heavily on a body mass index cutoff, or a percentage of an expected weight, risk misjudging patients for several reasons that clinicians describe:

  • A person can be medically unstable at a weight that looks within range, especially after rapid weight loss, with purging or when the weight started high.
  • Several eating disorders, including bulimia, binge eating disorder and avoidant or restrictive food intake disorder, are not defined by low weight at all.
  • Weight can rise during treatment while thoughts, behaviors and medical risks remain serious, and the plan can read a weight gain as proof that care is no longer needed.
  • Fluid shifts and measurement conditions can make a single weight misleading.

The point for a family is practical: if the plan's rationale cites only a weight or a BMI, ask the plan to name every criterion it applied and how it weighed the clinical facts, including vital signs, labs, behaviors and prior treatment failures. A reviewer deciding on one number has not considered the rest of the record. The federal parity law, explained in the mental health parity law: what insurers must treat equally, requires comparable treatment of mental health and medical benefits, and it is fair to ask in writing how the plan's process for this level of care compares to the one it uses for a comparable medical stay.

What a treatment team documents, and why it matters

The reviewer sees only what the program sends. A clinician's notes that are thorough and dated give the reviewer something to approve; sparse notes give the reviewer room to deny. Items a team can document, and a family can ask the team about:

  1. Vital signs and trends, including heart rate and blood pressure changes on standing, and the dates.
  2. Laboratory and ECG results and whether they are abnormal.
  3. Weight history, including the rate of loss before admission and the weight trend since.
  4. Meal completion, for example what share of meals and supplements are finished without support.
  5. Behavior counts, such as the number of purging episodes or restricted days per week.
  6. Failed or inadequate lower levels of care, with dates and what happened.
  7. Co-occurring conditions and safety concerns.
  8. Why the lower level is unsafe or unavailable, for example a long waitlist for the program the plan prefers, or no in-network provider within reach.

A parent can help by keeping a dated log of what happens at home, because a plan's reviewer weighs facts more than adjectives.

What a step-down decision looks like

Say a patient is in a partial hospitalization program five days a week, and the plan's review at the end of the third week says the patient can move to intensive outpatient care, three days a week. The plan's notice gives a date after which it will not pay for partial hospitalization.

The patient's team disagrees, because the patient still skips meals at home and has had a drop in weight in the past week. The family has three choices at that moment: step down as the plan says; continue the current level and appeal; or ask the team for a different plan. Continuing while appealing carries financial risk, as this illustration shows.

Say the plan's allowed amount for partial hospitalization is $700 a day, or $3,500 for a five-day week, the deductible is met and the plan pays 80% in network. The family's share is 20% of $3,500 = $700 a week. If the plan has denied the days and the family continues anyway, the denied days are not covered. Two more weeks would cost 2 × $3,500 = $7,000 if the appeal fails, against 2 × $700 = $1,400 if the appeal succeeds or the plan reverses. The difference is $5,600. These are invented numbers, but they show why the question for the program is "What do you bill the family for days the plan denies while an appeal is pending?" and why that answer should be in writing.

Compare the lower level: say intensive outpatient is allowed at $350 a day, three days a week, which is $1,050 a week. At 20%, the family pays $210 a week. Cost is not the reason to choose a level of care, and a lower weekly cost does not make it the right level. The numbers matter because they set the risk of continuing without approval. The plan's out-of-pocket maximum also limits the family's share of in-network covered care each plan year.

How to appeal a step-down

  1. Get the notice. It states the decision, the criteria used, the last covered date and the deadline to appeal.
  2. Ask for an expedited review if the patient is still in treatment and a delay could seriously harm health. The treating clinician usually makes this request.
  3. Ask for a peer-to-peer call. A strong call has the treating physician reviewing vital signs, labs, behaviors and failed attempts at lower levels. The post on peer-to-peer review mistakes that cost patients the approval covers common mistakes.
  4. File a written appeal with the clinician's letter, the records and your own short account. See how to appeal a denied health insurance claim, step by step.
  5. If the plan upholds the decision, request external review by an independent reviewer. See external review explained: when an independent reviewer decides.
  6. Contact the regulator: the state insurance department for fully insured plans, or the employer's benefits office for a self-funded plan.

The post on denied residential or intensive mental health care: parity and criteria has more on asking for the plan's criteria, and the post on what happens with insurance if my teenager needs a psychiatric hospital stay? describes how day-limit reviews work in a hospital.

Questions to ask the plan's reviewer

  • What are the exact criteria and version number you used, and which specific criterion is not met?
  • What clinical information did you receive, and what additional information would change the decision?
  • Does the reviewer have training in eating disorders? Can the appeal be reviewed by someone who does?
  • Which lower-level program is in network, has an opening and is within a reasonable distance? Can you name it?
  • If the patient worsens at the lower level, what is the process and timeline for returning to the higher one, and will the plan require a new authorization or waiting period?
  • When is the next review, and who sends the information?
  • If no in-network program is available at the recommended level, will the plan agree to a network gap exception?

Key takeaways

  • Plans approve each level of eating disorder care separately, and a concurrent review can step a patient down while treatment is under way.
  • The decision rests on medical stability, behaviors, response to earlier care and the home environment, not on weight alone, and a rationale that cites only weight is worth challenging.
  • The reviewer sees only what the program sends, so thorough dated documentation of vital signs, labs, behaviors and failed lower levels matters.
  • Before continuing care during an appeal, ask the program in writing what the family will owe if the appeal fails.
  • Ask for the criteria in writing, request a peer-to-peer call and an expedited appeal, and use external review and the regulator if the plan upholds its decision.

Terms used in this guide

Related guides

Latest on this topic