Blog

What changed in my life this year that should change my open enrollment choices?

A fill-in worksheet that turns a new doctor, drug, dependent, income change or move into plan-choice questions, with two worked examples and pass/fail triggers.

A health plan is chosen for a particular person in a particular year, and the person changes. A plan that fit in January can be wrong for the next January because a doctor retired, a prescription was added, a child was born, or income moved. Picking "the same plan again" is a decision too, and it is usually made without the information that would test it.

This worksheet is meant to be filled in with a pen. Part 1 lists the life changes and the plan question each one raises. Part 2 turns those questions into one total-cost number per plan. Part 3 sets the pass/fail triggers that say whether to keep the plan or switch. Two filled-in examples with round invented numbers show the whole process.

Part 1: the life-change inventory

Go down the list and mark every line that is true for anyone covered. For each mark, the right-hand column says what to look up.

Change this year Question it raises for next year's plan Where to look
A new doctor or specialist Is each one in the plan's network, and at the right tier? Plan's provider directory, then a call to the office
A new prescription or dose change Is the drug on the formulary, at what tier, with what restrictions? Plan's drug list; prior authorization and step rules
A planned surgery, treatment or pregnancy What will I likely spend, and how fast do I reach the out-of-pocket maximum? Summary of Benefits and Coverage; the plan's cost estimator
A new dependent (birth, adoption, marriage) Who must be added, by what date, and at what price? Employer benefits office or marketplace
A dependent leaving (aging out at 26, divorce) Does anyone lose coverage, and is there a deadline to replace it? Plan documents; marketplace
An income change up or down Does the premium credit change, or does Medicaid or CHIP now apply? Marketplace estimate; state agency
A spouse's new job or lost job Is there a new employer offer, or a loss of one? Spouse's benefits office
A move Do the same plans, doctors and hospitals exist where I'll live? Marketplace or plan; the new address
Turning 65, or someone nearing it Does Medicare enter the picture, and what does it do to the rest? Medicare, SHIP counselor
Health that got better or worse Will I use more or less care than last year? Last year's EOBs and claims

Write the marks here: _______________________________________________

Every blank line on the table is a good sign. It means the plan decision is mostly about price and renewal changes. Each mark is a reason to check, and the checks in Part 2 are how.

Some marks need a phone call before they need arithmetic. For a new doctor, ask the office which plan names it bills under today, not just whether it "takes insurance," and ask whether the doctor expects to stay in that network through the next plan year. For a new drug, ask the pharmacy or prescriber whether a cheaper equivalent exists, because that changes the formulary question. For a pregnancy or a planned procedure, ask the hospital which facility fees and professional fees will be billed separately; each can fall under a different network status. Write the answers next to the mark, with the date and the name of the person who gave them.

Part 2: from questions to one number per plan

A plan comparison should end in a single annual figure per plan: what you would pay if the year goes the way you expect. The formula is short.

Annual cost = 12 x monthly premium + your share of expected care

Your share of expected care, for a plan with a deductible and coinsurance, works this way:

  • If expected covered spending (the amount the plan would allow) is below the deductible, you pay all of it.
  • If it is above the deductible, you pay the deductible plus your coinsurance percentage of the spending above it.
  • Whatever that comes to, you never pay more than the plan's out-of-pocket maximum for covered in-network care.

Fill in one column per plan:

Current plan Alternative 1 Alternative 2
Monthly premium $____ $____ $____
Premium x 12 $____ $____ $____
Deductible $____ $____ $____
Coinsurance ____% ____% ____%
Out-of-pocket maximum $____ $____ $____
Expected allowed spending $____ $____ $____
Your share of care (formula above, capped) $____ $____ $____
Annual cost $____ $____ $____

Do the calculation twice: once for a quiet year (routine care only) and once for a heavy year (the surgery, the delivery, the flare-up). The gap between the two shows how much risk each plan leaves you with. The deductible vs premium break-even calculator automates the arithmetic, and how to estimate your total yearly health care costs for a plan explains where to get the spending figures. If you have last year's explanations of benefits, Use last year's EOBs to forecast next year's health costs shows how to turn them into a forecast.

Two cautions. The formula assumes simple coinsurance after a deductible. Many plans use flat copays for some services, separate drug deductibles, or a different structure for the first visits; the plan's Summary of Benefits and Coverage tells you which. And the spending you expect is an estimate. The point of the worksheet is to see how sensitive the answer is.

Worked example 1: a planned surgery

Say Priya, 34, has a planned knee operation in the spring. She also started a new daily drug in the fall and has a new surgeon. All figures below are invented for the illustration.

Current plan Alternative
Monthly premium $350 $460
Premium x 12 $4,200 $5,520
Deductible $4,000 $1,500
Coinsurance 20% 20%
Out-of-pocket maximum $7,000 $5,000

Heavy year. Priya expects $30,000 in allowed charges for surgery, hospital, therapy and the drug.

  • Current plan: $4,000 + 20% x ($30,000 - $4,000) = $4,000 + $5,200 = $9,200. That exceeds the $7,000 cap, so she pays $7,000. Annual cost: $4,200 + $7,000 = $11,200.
  • Alternative: $1,500 + 20% x ($30,000 - $1,500) = $1,500 + $5,700 = $7,200. That exceeds the $5,000 cap, so she pays $5,000. Annual cost: $5,520 + $5,000 = $10,520.

The alternative saves $680.

Quiet year. If the surgery did not happen and allowed charges were only $3,000:

  • Current plan: $3,000 is below the $4,000 deductible, so she pays all of it. Annual cost: $4,200 + $3,000 = $7,200.
  • Alternative: $1,500 + 20% x ($3,000 - $1,500) = $1,500 + $300 = $1,800. Annual cost: $5,520 + $1,800 = $7,320.

In a quiet year, the alternative costs $120 more. So Priya is buying protection: $120 extra if nothing happens, $680 less if the surgery does. Surgery is planned, so the heavy year is the likely one.

Then the pass/fail checks: Is the surgeon in the alternative's network? Is the hospital? Is the new drug on its formulary at a tier she can afford? If any answer is no, the $680 saving does not matter. I know I'm having surgery next year. Should I buy gold instead of silver? runs the same method for a bigger gap.

Worked example 2: a spouse's new job

Say Dev, 41, and Lena, 40, are a couple. Dev has a chronic condition with a monthly drug and quarterly specialist visits. Lena has just started a job with a health plan. Dev can stay on a marketplace plan or be added to Lena's plan. Again, the numbers are made up.

Dev on marketplace plan (after any credit) Dev added to Lena's employer plan
Monthly cost to Dev $210 $260 extra per month
Cost x 12 $2,520 $3,120
Deductible $3,000 $1,500
Coinsurance 30% 20%
Out-of-pocket maximum $8,000 $5,000

Dev's expected allowed spending for the year is $6,000.

  • Marketplace: $3,000 + 30% x ($6,000 - $3,000) = $3,000 + $900 = $3,900, below the $8,000 cap. Annual cost: $2,520 + $3,900 = $6,420.
  • Employer plan: $1,500 + 20% x ($6,000 - $1,500) = $1,500 + $900 = $2,400, below the $5,000 cap. Annual cost: $3,120 + $2,400 = $5,520.

The employer plan is $900 cheaper at this level of use. But the worksheet is not finished until Part 3 questions are answered: Does Lena's plan cover Dev's drug at the same tier? Does it include his specialist? Does adding Dev to the employer plan affect his eligibility for a marketplace credit if he later wants one back? The last question depends on the employer plan's affordability under the rules and is worth a call to a navigator or tax professional; How ACA premium tax credits work: income, benchmark plan, your share covers the mechanism.

Part 3: the pass/fail triggers

Set your own thresholds before you look at prices, so the numbers do not bargain with you. Here is a set of triggers. Mark each one yes or no, and write your personal threshold in the blank.

Fail triggers: the current plan no longer works.

  • A doctor or hospital you must keep is out of network. ______
  • A drug you take regularly is dropped from the formulary, or moves to a tier that raises your yearly drug cost by more than $____.
  • The plan is being discontinued or its service area no longer includes your address.
  • Your expected spending is high enough that the plan's out-of-pocket maximum, not its premium, is the real cost, and another plan caps lower for a premium difference smaller than the cap difference.

Switch triggers: a better option exists.

  • The best alternative's annual cost, in the heavy-year and quiet-year calculation both, is lower by at least $____. (Many people set a threshold of a few hundred dollars to make a switch worth the effort. Yours may differ.)
  • A new employer offer, Medicare eligibility or Medicaid or CHIP eligibility makes another program available.
  • A new dependent needs coverage and the cost to add them differs enough across options to change the total.

Stay triggers: the current plan still wins.

  • Every provider and drug passes.
  • The cost difference between plans is below your threshold.
  • The change you would be making would put a family member through a transition (a pregnancy, ongoing treatment) that is hard to repeat. If you are deep into treatment, ask the plan about continuity of care rules before you switch.

If you are pregnant or planning to be, Planning a pregnancy next year, how do I choose a plan month by month? works month by month, and the doctor list in make a doctor and hospital list before you compare plans is the quickest way to answer the network question for everyone in the household.

The income line deserves its own check

An income change affects marketplace premium credits in a way that is not obvious. For plan year 2027, credit amounts are tied to the 2026 poverty guidelines and to a table of required contribution percentages that runs from 2.15% to 10.22% of income (Rev. Proc. 2026-26, as of November 2026). The enhanced credits that removed the 400%-of-poverty cutoff expired at the end of 2025, so the cutoff applies again. As derived arithmetic (not published figures), 400% of the 2026 guideline is about $63,840 for one person and $132,000 for a family of four.

That means a raise that crosses the line can matter much more than its size suggests. If your income estimate is near it, run ACA subsidy estimator with the number as it truly will be, not as it was last year. A change that moves a family toward the lower end of the table can also open Medicaid or CHIP for a child. Ask the marketplace, the state agency or a navigator to confirm.

What to do with the finished worksheet

  1. Staple it to your plan documents and the plan's renewal notice.
  2. Check the employer or marketplace deadline and set a date to decide at least a week early.
  3. If a mark in Part 1 triggers a special enrollment right (a move, a new dependent, a loss of coverage), note that an extra window may exist outside open enrollment; special enrollment periods explained: qualifying life events and deadlines lists the common ones.
  4. Put the date on your calendar to repeat next year. The same form works annually, and last year's version shows what you assumed.

Key takeaways

  • Every change in who needs care, what drugs they take, who is on the plan, where you live or what you earn is a reason to test the plan, not to renew it by default.
  • One annual figure per plan, 12 x premium plus your share of expected care capped at the out-of-pocket maximum, makes plans comparable. Run it for a quiet year and a heavy year.
  • A cheaper plan fails if your doctor, hospital or drug is not covered; check those first.
  • Decide your thresholds for switching before you look at prices.
  • An income change can matter more than it seems for credits; use the estimator with the real number.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic