Blog
Two plans, same premium, different drug tiers. Which one costs me less?
Full-year arithmetic for two hypothetical plans with the same premium but different drug tiers and deductibles, and the point where the deductible decides.
When two plans charge the same premium, the choice looks like a coin flip. For a person who takes a brand-name drug every month it is not, because the plans can place that drug on different tiers, attach different deductibles to the tiers and apply a different formula after the deductible is met. The result can be a gap of hundreds of dollars a year in either direction, and which plan wins can flip depending on what the drug costs.
This post compares two hypothetical plans line by line for a person on one brand-name drug and two generics. Every number is a round figure invented for illustration, not the price of any drug or plan. The aim is to show the arithmetic you can repeat with the real numbers from the plan documents.
The setup
Meet two plans. Both charge $450 a month, so the premium is $5,400 a year on either, and it drops out of the comparison. Both have the same combined out-of-pocket maximum, $6,000 a year, and we assume the person has no other medical costs this year.
The person takes three drugs, each filled every 30 days, twelve fills a year:
- Brand drug B: the plan's negotiated price is $600 per fill in the main scenario. Later we try $200 and $400.
- Generic G1: $15 per fill.
- Generic G2: $30 per fill.
The two plans place and price them differently.
| Plan North | Plan South | |
|---|---|---|
| Premium | $450 a month | $450 a month |
| Brand drug B tier | Tier 3 (non-preferred brand) | Tier 2 (preferred brand) |
| Drug deductible | $400, applies to tier 3 and above | $1,200, applies to tiers 2 and above |
| Brand drug cost after deductible | 30% coinsurance | $75 copay per fill |
| Generics (tier 1) | $10 copay per fill, no deductible | $5 copay per fill, no deductible |
| Out-of-pocket maximum | $6,000 | $6,000 |
Plan South looks more generous: a lower tier for the brand drug, a smaller flat charge and cheaper generics. Plan North looks more modest but has a much smaller deductible. Which costs less depends on the arithmetic.
One simplification: assume the deductible falls on whole fills, so no fill straddles it. The numbers below were chosen so that holds.
Full-year arithmetic at a $600 brand price
Plan North, brand drug.
- First fill: $600. The $400 deductible is paid first. The remaining $200 is subject to 30% coinsurance: 0.30 × $200 = $60. The member pays $400 + $60 = $460.
- Fills 2 through 12 (11 fills): 30% × $600 = $180 each. 11 × $180 = $1,980.
- Brand total: $460 + $1,980 = $2,440.
Plan North, generics. G1: 12 × $10 = $120. G2: 12 × $10 = $120. Total $240.
Plan North, all drugs: $2,440 + $240 = $2,680.
Plan South, brand drug.
- Fills 1 and 2: each $600, which together equals the $1,200 deductible. The member pays $1,200.
- Fills 3 through 12 (10 fills): $75 copay each = $750.
- Brand total: $1,200 + $750 = $1,950.
Plan South, generics. G1: 12 × $5 = $60. G2: 12 × $5 = $60. Total $120.
Plan South, all drugs: $1,950 + $120 = $2,070.
So at a $600 brand price, Plan South costs $2,680 − $2,070 = $610 less over the year, in spite of the $1,200 deductible that looks so large at first. Neither total reaches the $6,000 out-of-pocket maximum.
The reason is the formula after the deductible. Plan North's 30% of a $600 drug is $180 every month, and Plan South's flat $75 is far lower. The $800 difference between the two deductibles ($1,200 versus $400) is soon outweighed by the $105 a month gap in the charge per fill, though the deductible arrives first in the year.
Where the deductible dominates: cheaper brand prices
Now vary the brand price, keeping everything else the same. Because both plans' formulas depend on the price, the winner changes.
Brand price $400 per fill.
- Plan North: first fill pays the full $400 deductible, 0 left for coinsurance. Fills 2 to 12 (11 fills): 30% × $400 = $120 each = $1,320. Brand total $1,720. Plus generics $240 = $1,960.
- Plan South: fills 1 to 3 are $400 each = $1,200, the deductible. Fills 4 to 12 (9 fills): $75 each = $675. Brand total $1,875. Plus generics $120 = $1,995.
Brand price $200 per fill.
- Plan North: fills 1 and 2 pay $200 each = $400, the deductible. Fills 3 to 12 (10 fills): 30% × $200 = $60 each = $600. Brand total $1,000. Plus generics $240 = $1,240.
- Plan South: fills 1 to 6 are $200 each = $1,200. Fills 7 to 12 (6 fills): $75 each = $450. Brand total $1,650. Plus generics $120 = $1,770.
| Brand price per fill | Plan North, all drugs | Plan South, all drugs | Cheaper plan |
|---|---|---|---|
| $200 | $1,240 | $1,770 | North, by $530 |
| $400 | $1,960 | $1,995 | North, by $35 |
| $600 | $2,680 | $2,070 | South, by $610 |
The crossover sits between $400 and $600 a fill. Below it, Plan South's big deductible absorbs a large part of what you pay, and the generous copay after it matters less because there are fewer fills left to benefit. Above it, the flat copay beats the percentage. In the example a drug priced at $400 makes the two plans almost identical, within $35 for the year.
The general lesson: a flat copay after a large deductible pays off only if the drug is costly enough or taken often enough to reach and then use the deductible for many fills. A percentage after a small deductible pays off for a cheaper drug.
A much costlier drug and the out-of-pocket maximum
Push the price higher, to $1,200 a fill, and the gap widens in the same direction.
- Plan North: first fill pays the $400 deductible plus 30% of the remaining $800, which is $240, so $640. Fills 2 to 12: 30% × $1,200 = $360 each, 11 × $360 = $3,960. Brand total $4,600. Plus generics $240 = $4,840.
- Plan South: fill 1 is $1,200, which is the full deductible. Fills 2 to 12: 11 × $75 = $825. Brand total $2,025. Plus generics $120 = $2,145.
Plan South is $2,695 cheaper at that price. Raise the price again, to $2,000 a fill, and Plan North's formula alone would reach $880 for the first fill (the $400 deductible plus 30% of $1,600, which is $480) plus 11 × $600 = $6,600 for the rest, a total of $7,480 for the brand drug, plus $240 for the generics, $7,720. The $6,000 out-of-pocket maximum stops that: once your combined spending reaches it, covered in-network costs for the rest of the year fall to zero. That cap, not the tier, becomes the ceiling for Plan North.
Two cautions come with this. First, a cap holds only for covered, in-network spending, so a drug filled out of network or outside the formulary may not count. Second, the cap is the plan's maximum for medical and drug costs together in this example, and real plans may keep a separate drug maximum or none. The summary of benefits and coverage says which.
The first three months look different from the full year
The totals above assume you take the drug all twelve months and stay on the plan. If you do not, the comparison changes. At the $600 price, over the first three months:
- Plan North: $460 + 2 × $180 = $820 for the brand, plus generics 3 × $20 = $60, for $880.
- Plan South: $600 + $600 + $75 = $1,275 for the brand, plus generics 3 × $10 = $30, for $1,305.
For someone who stops the drug early because the doctor changes the prescription, or leaves the plan after a job change or a move, Plan North's lower deductible costs less. The plan that wins over twelve months is not the one that costs less in month three. The deductible resets each plan year, so if your coverage starts mid-year, the deductible is charged again in the new year as well, and the first months of each year are the costliest on Plan South.
What the table leaves out
Real plans have more moving parts than the hypothetical ones. Before you rely on a comparison like this, check:
- The actual negotiated price. The $600 above is invented. The plan's price for your drug, and your share of it, is in the plan's drug cost lookup tool or on the member portal after you enroll. Before enrolling, ask the plan or look at the plan documents.
- Whether the drug deductible is separate or combined. Some plans use a single medical deductible for everything, so your drugs and your doctor visits compete for the same dollars.
- Whether a deductible applies to your generics. In this example they sit outside the deductible. In some plans they do not.
- Out-of-pocket maximum. If your total spending, including medical care, would reach the maximum, the cost of the drugs beyond that point is $0. For an expensive specialty drug, the maximum may decide the whole year, and the gap between plans becomes the difference in maximums.
- Restrictions. A drug on a preferred tier with prior authorization or step therapy may cost less on paper but require paperwork, which How do I check my prescriptions on a plan's formulary before I enroll? covers.
- Coupons and assistance. Manufacturer copay assistance can lower what you pay, but some plans use accumulators that do not count the assistance toward your deductible. copay accumulators and maximizers: why coupons may not count describes the difference.
- Pharmacy and mail-order pricing. A 90-day supply or a preferred pharmacy can cost less than the same drug filled 30 days at a time.
how to estimate your total yearly health care costs for a plan builds the arithmetic for a whole year of care, and the health plan comparison calculator on this site does the same calculation for several plans if you enter your own figures.
Who each plan suits, in this example
Neither plan is better in the abstract. Using the numbers above:
- Plan North suits a person whose brand drug costs less per fill, whose prescriptions might change during the year, who expects to be on the plan only part of it, or who wants smaller bills early in the year. Its percentage formula tracks the price: when the drug is cheap, the bill is small.
- Plan South suits a person on a costly brand drug taken every month for the full year, who can cover the first two months of $600 fills and wants predictable bills afterward. Its flat copay caps the cost of each later fill.
- Neither is clearly better at the middle price, where the totals differ by about $35, and other features of the plan, such as the doctors and the hospital, can reasonably decide.
These are descriptions of the arithmetic, not recommendations of any plan type. Premium differences, the medical side of the plan and the doctors in the network all belong in the same decision, which Higher premium or higher deductible? How to find the break-even explores from the premium angle.
Where to find each number
Most of what the comparison needs is in three documents, and each is free to request before you enroll:
- The summary of benefits and coverage lists the cost for each drug tier, whether a deductible applies to drugs and the out-of-pocket maximum. How to read a Summary of Benefits and Coverage shows how to read it.
- The formulary names the tier for each of your drugs and any restrictions.
- The plan's drug pricing tool, where it exists, shows the plan's price for your drug at a given pharmacy. If there is no tool, the member services line can give a price quote for a named drug, strength and quantity, though not always before enrollment.
If any piece is missing, say so in your own notes and treat the estimate as a range. A navigator or the benefits office can often fill the gap.
Running your own version
- List each drug with its fills per year.
- For each plan, find the tier, the tier's cost and the drug deductible.
- Compute each drug's yearly cost the way the examples did: deductible first, then the copay or coinsurance on each remaining fill.
- Add the premiums if the premiums differ.
- Run the numbers again with a different price, a lower dose or only the first three months, and note where the answer flips.
A marketplace navigator, a licensed broker or your employer's benefits office can help you find the plan's price for your drug and check the figures against the plan documents.
Key takeaways
- With equal premiums, the drug costs decide: tier placement, the drug deductible and the formula after it (copay or coinsurance) all matter.
- At a $600 brand price Plan South costs $2,070 against Plan North's $2,680; at $200 the order reverses, with North at $1,240 and South at $1,770.
- A larger deductible with a flat copay favors expensive drugs taken all year; a smaller deductible with coinsurance favors cheaper drugs or part-year use.
- Compare the first three months as well as the full year if you may stop the drug or change plans.
- Confirm the real negotiated price, the deductible's scope and any restrictions in the plan documents before relying on any table.