Medigap and senior market carriers

ManhattanLife: plans, ratings and contacts

Privately held Houston insurer of life, annuity and supplemental health products; it stopped taking new Medicare Supplement applications on April 30, 2025.

Also known as Manhattan Life, ManhattanLife Insurance and Annuity Company, Manhattan Life Group

Where it sellsNo longer sells Medicare Supplement to new applicants (since April 30, 2025); other products vary by state
Member services800-877-7703

Contact

Member services 800-877-7703
Website manhattanlife.com
Headquarters address PO Box 925568, Houston, TX 77292-5568

Company

Legal name ManhattanLife Insurance and Annuity Company
Headquarters Houston, Texas
Ownership Privately held and independent
Parent company Manhattan Life Group Inc.
Status No longer sells Medicare Supplement to new applicants

Where and what

Where it sells No longer sells Medicare Supplement to new applicants (since April 30, 2025); other products vary by state
Plan types Accident, cancer and heart attack/stroke, dental/vision/hearing, hospital indemnity, out-of-pocket gap, short-term care, final expense, life insurance, annuities; Medicare Supplement for existing policyholders

Fit

Best suited to People who already hold a ManhattanLife Medicare Supplement policy, and shoppers looking at fixed-benefit supplemental products sold by licensed agents.

Plans and products

  • Accident
  • Cancer/Heart & Stroke
  • Dental/Vision/Hearing
  • Hospital Indemnity
  • Out-of-Pocket (GAP)
  • Short-Term Care
  • Whole life
  • Annuities

Brands and plan names

  • ManhattanLife
  • The Manhattan Life Insurance Company
  • Western United Life
  • Standard Life & Casualty

ManhattanLife is a life and supplemental health insurer based in Houston, Texas, that describes itself as privately held and independent. It once sold Medicare Supplement (Medigap) policies and still services the ones it issued, but it stopped accepting new Medigap applications on April 30, 2025, according to a notice posted by an insurance marketing organization for agents. Its other products are mostly fixed-benefit supplemental coverage, life insurance and annuities, not comprehensive health insurance.

Overview

The ManhattanLife name covers several legal entities, and the company says the plan or policy in your hands is issued by the entity named in the contract. Its website lists The Manhattan Life Insurance Company, ManhattanLife Insurance and Annuity Company, Western United Life Insurance Company and Standard Life & Casualty Insurance Company, all affiliates of Manhattan Life Group Inc. The company is not a health maintenance organization and does not run a provider network; its health products pay cash benefits or reimburse certain costs rather than contracting with doctors.

Because many consumer review sites still list ManhattanLife among Medigap carriers, readers sometimes assume it is a current option. For example, a June 2026 review on The Senior List describes it as a Medigap carrier offering Plans A, C, F, G and N. That description conflicts with the April 2025 notice described below, and with the company's own senior-products page, which lists no Medicare Supplement plan. Confirm status with the company or your state insurance department before relying on any list.

History

The company's website says it was founded in 1850 in New York, after a cholera outbreak, to protect widows and orphans. Its timeline records a 1864 incontestability clause (a promise that a policy cannot be challenged after a set period) and a 1894 headquarters building at 66 Broadway that it calls America's first skyscraper. The home office moved to West 57th Street in New York in 1958.

In 2000, a private buyer purchased the company, and it is now run from Houston. The same history page says annuities and voluntary benefits joined the product line between 2014 and 2018, and a new brand launched in 2019. In 2025 the company marked its 175th anniversary. Mailing addresses on its contact page are in Houston, Spokane and Salt Lake City; the page lists no street address for a headquarters.

Plans and products

The company's individual and senior pages list these product lines: accident coverage; cancer, heart attack and stroke coverage; dental, vision and hearing plans; home health care; hospital indemnity; an out-of-pocket "gap" plan; short-term care; and other ancillary benefits. It also sells whole life insurance and annuities, and employer products such as group accident, critical illness, hospitalization and short-term disability benefits. A mortgage-lending section appears on the site as well.

Fixed-benefit plans of this kind pay a set amount when a covered event happens, regardless of the actual bill. They are not minimum essential coverage and do not replace a major medical plan; see fixed indemnity plan and accident, hospital indemnity and critical illness plans explained for how they work and what they leave out. ManhattanLife's product pages say not all plans are available in every state.

The Medicare Supplement exit

An agent-marketing post dated April 7, 2025 says ManhattanLife was discontinuing its Medicare Supplement program for new business. According to that post, agents received official notice on April 4, 2025, online contracting was turned off, and April 30, 2025 was the last day to submit new applications. The post says current in-force policies continue to be serviced as usual and gives no reason for the decision. I did not find the company's own public announcement, so treat the dates as reported by a third party.

For people who hold a policy, the practical points are these. A Medigap policy sold under federal and state rules is guaranteed renewable, so the insurer cannot cancel it because of your health; premiums can still change, subject to state rate rules. People shopping for a new Medigap policy need a different insurer, and outside a protected window an insurer may use medical underwriting. See medigap, medigap open enrollment: the six-month window and guaranteed issue and, for carriers still selling, Mutual of Omaha and Physicians Mutual.

Where it sells

The company says only that products vary by state and does not publish a state list on the pages opened. This profile therefore marks its footprint as nationwide in the machine fields while noting that each product has its own state list; check the product page or an agent for your state. Because ManhattanLife is based in Texas, see Texas for the state regulator.

Ratings and reputation

The ManhattanLife site says it holds a Better Business Bureau accreditation rated A+ and a Financial Stability Rating of A, without naming the agency that issued the stability rating or its date. One third-party listing shows an AM Best rating in the B++ range, but its date could not be confirmed, so no AM Best rating is stated here; AM Best publishes current ratings for insurers on its own site. I found no regulatory action or lawsuit in the pages I opened.

Enrolling and member service

ManhattanLife sells through licensed agents; its site offers a form to have an agent contact you, and the Contact Us page offers a number finder. Its contact page lists separate lines by product, including the Medicare Supplement line (800-877-7703), life customer service (800-877-7705), dental, vision and hearing (800-999-2971) and a line for all other individual health inquiries (800-879-6542). Claims go to mailing addresses listed on the page, with a File a Claim page online.

Complaints about a policy can go to the insurance department of the state where you live, which also publishes complaint data and license records; see how to file a complaint with your state insurance department.

Who it suits

  • Strengths: a long operating history, a range of low-cost fixed-benefit products, and continued servicing of existing Medigap policies.
  • Weaknesses: no new Medigap sales since April 30, 2025; supplemental products pay fixed amounts that may not match an actual bill; no network to lower prices.

How to contact

Service Number or URL
Medicare Supplement (existing policies) 800-877-7703
Life customer service 800-877-7705
Dental, vision and hearing 800-999-2971
All other individual health 800-879-6542
Website https://www.manhattanlife.com

Sources

  1. manhattanlife.com
  2. manhattanlife.com/about-us/history
  3. manhattanlife.com/contact-us
  4. goldencareagent.com/manhattanlife-to-discontinue-its-medicare-supplement-program/
  5. theseniorlist.com/medigap/best/

Facts were checked against these sources on the review date below. Plans, footprints, ratings and phone numbers change every year: confirm with the company, the marketplace or your state insurance department before you rely on them.

Profile last reviewed November 16, 2026

Latest ManhattanLife news

Compare with similar companies

Terms to know

Related guides

Related states