Ohio insurers

Company Type Where it sells Size AM Best
Medical Mutual of OhioCleveland-based mutual insurer selling individual, employer and Medicare plans in Ohio. A Blue plan until 1997; proposed a 21.6% 2027 marketplace increase. Regional and provider-owned plans Ohio More than 1.2 million Ohioans (company, November 2024) —
Liberty HealthShareCanton, Ohio sharing ministry, not insurance: members pool monthly shares toward each other's medical bills. Regulators and the press have scrutinized it. Health care sharing ministries (not insurance) Offered nationally by its own account; sold under the name Liberty HealthShare, with state regulators disputing its status in at least New Mexico 185,900 families helped, cumulative (company website, 2026) —
Christian Healthcare Ministries (CHM)Barberton, Ohio nonprofit sharing ministry founded in 1981. Not insurance: Christian members share eligible medical bills, with no guarantee of payment. Health care sharing ministries (not insurance) Members in all 50 states by the ministry's account; state rules for sharing ministries differ Over $14 billion in members' medical bills satisfied since 1981 (CHM website, 2026); member count not published on its site —
Paramount Health (Paramount Insurance Company)Toledo, Ohio insurer sold by ProMedica to Medical Mutual of Ohio in 2024. Sells Medicare Advantage, ACA, employer and short-term plans in Ohio and Michigan. Regional and provider-owned plans Ohio and Michigan primarily, according to the 2024 acquisition announcement; its own boilerplate said six Midwest states More than 77,000 health plan members and 308,000 dental plan members (January 2024 announcement) —
AultCareCanton, Ohio health plan tied to the Aultman hospital system. It sells employer plans, Medicare Advantage and Medigap; it left ACA individual plans after 2025. Regional and provider-owned plans Stark County and surrounding northeast Ohio counties; the PrimeTime Medicare Advantage plan listed 11 counties in 2023 — —

A directory of the health insurance companies consumers deal with, by type. Where each sells, and what it sells there, is under "By state and plan type".