Blog

Two silver plans look alike: how do I choose between them?

Compare two same-metal plans by deductible, copays, tiers, drug tier, out-of-pocket maximum and network, using two invented plans and a decision list.

Two plans with the same metal level are built to pay about the same share of costs for a large group of people, yet they can behave very differently for one person. The metal label is an average across everyone; the plan design decides who pays more and when. If your two silver plans are close in price, the choice usually comes down to how you use care: a few predictable visits and a prescription, or a year with a hospital stay.

One fact simplifies the shopping. The premium tax credit is set by the benchmark plan in your area, not by the plan you pick, so the credit is the same whichever silver plan you choose. Whatever the difference in sticker price between the two plans, you keep all of it or you pay all of it.

What "same metal level" does and does not tell you

A silver plan is designed so that the plan pays about 70% of the average covered costs for a standard population, and the enrollee pays about 30% through deductibles, copays and coinsurance. That is an actuarial average, and it says nothing about your year. Two silver plans can reach 70% in opposite ways: one with a low deductible and higher coinsurance, another with a high deductible and rich benefits after it, or one with copays for common services that skip the deductible.

The averages also hide who gets hurt. A plan that charges $30 for a primary care visit and $10 for a generic prescription looks generous to a person who sees a doctor six times a year. A plan that charges the full allowed price until a $4,500 deductible is met looks harsh to that same person but can look excellent to someone with a $40,000 hospital bill.

Two invented plans

The plans below are hypothetical, built so the arithmetic is easy to follow. They are not real products and the numbers are not typical prices. Both use round figures and both stay under the federal limit on out-of-pocket costs, which is $12,000 for one person in plan year 2027.

Feature Plan A (copays first) Plan B (deductible first)
Monthly premium $540 $495
Yearly premium $6,480 $5,940
Deductible (one person) $3,000 $4,500
Primary care visit $30 copay, deductible not required Full price until the deductible, then 20%
Specialist visit $60 copay, deductible not required Full price until the deductible, then 20%
Generic drugs $10 copay Full price until the deductible, then $15
Preferred brand drugs $45 copay Full price until the deductible, then 30%
Imaging, procedures, hospital Deductible, then 30% Deductible, then 20%
Out-of-pocket maximum $8,500 $8,000
HSA-eligible No Yes (in this illustration)

Plan A charges $45 more a month. For that, you get copays on everyday care and a lower deductible. Plan B charges less and asks for more before it starts to pay. This is the typical tension between two similarly priced silver plans.

Reading each row

Deductible versus copay structure. The deductible is what you pay before the plan begins sharing costs. A copay is a flat fee, and in Plan A it applies to common visits from the first day. A coinsurance percentage applies after the deductible. The question is which services skip the deductible, because that determines how soon the plan helps. The premium, deductible, copay and coinsurance explained simply guide covers the terms in detail.

Service tiers. Some plans group hospitals, labs, imaging centers or doctors into tiers and charge less at a preferred tier. Two plans with the same deductible can cost very different amounts for the same MRI depending on where the scan is done. See the My plan has tiers of doctors and hospitals, so how do tiers change what I pay? post for how tiers change what you pay.

The out-of-pocket maximum. This is the most you pay in a plan year for covered, in-network essential health benefits. Premiums, balance bills and services the plan does not cover do not count. A lower maximum helps most in a bad year. A higher premium for a plan with a lower maximum is the price of a smaller worst case.

Drug tier. Plans sort prescriptions into formulary tier levels, and the tier decides your cost. A drug can be a $10 copay on one plan, a $45 copay on another, and subject to the full deductible on a third. The Two plans, same premium, different drug tiers. Which one costs me less? post goes deeper on drugs.

Network. A plan with a lower premium may have a narrower network or leave out a hospital you use. The cost comparison means little if your doctor is out of network on one of the plans. The how to check whether a doctor or hospital is in your network guide explains how to verify, and it is worth calling the doctor's office, not only reading the plan's directory.

HSA eligibility. A health savings account needs a qualifying high-deductible plan, and plans that pay copays before the deductible generally do not qualify. Whether a plan is HSA-eligible is stated in its documents. The Is this plan HSA-eligible? A checklist to verify before you enroll post shows how to check.

Three years, same two plans

Say the same person uses each plan in three different years. Allowed amounts here are invented: a primary care visit is $150, a specialist visit $250, a generic prescription fill $20 and a preferred brand drug fill $300.

A quiet year

Two primary care visits, one specialist visit and twelve generic fills.

  • Plan A: visits cost 2 x $30 + $60 = $120; generics cost 12 x $10 = $120. Care total $240. Add the premium: $6,480 + $240 = $6,720.
  • Plan B: nothing reaches the deductible, so the person pays full prices: 2 x $150 + $250 + 12 x $20 = $300 + $250 + $240 = $790. Add the premium: $5,940 + $790 = $6,730.

A $10 difference is a tie. In a quiet year the cheaper premium of Plan B almost exactly offsets the lack of copays.

A moderate year

Four primary care visits, four specialist visits, twelve generic fills, one MRI at an allowed $1,200 and eight physical therapy visits at an allowed $120 each ($960).

  • Plan A: copays are 4 x $30 + 4 x $60 + 12 x $10 = $120 + $240 + $120 = $480. The MRI and therapy, $1,200 + $960 = $2,160, fall under the $3,000 deductible, so the person pays all of it. Care total $2,640. Add the premium: $6,480 + $2,640 = $9,120.
  • Plan B: everything is subject to the $4,500 deductible. Allowed amounts total 4 x $150 + 4 x $250 + 12 x $20 + $1,200 + $960 = $600 + $1,000 + $240 + $1,200 + $960 = $4,000, which is below the deductible, so the person pays it all. Add the premium: $5,940 + $4,000 = $9,940.

Plan A is $820 cheaper. Predictable visits and a mid-sized claim favor the copay structure.

A hospital year

The routine care above, plus a hospital stay with $30,000 in allowed charges, for a total of $34,000 on Plan B and $32,160 subject to the deductible on Plan A (the $30,000 stay plus the $2,160 MRI and therapy).

  • Plan A: deductible $3,000, then 30% of the other $29,160, which is $8,748. With the $480 in copays, that would reach $12,228. The out-of-pocket maximum caps it at $8,500. Add the premium: $6,480 + $8,500 = $14,980.
  • Plan B: deductible $4,500, then 20% of the other $29,500, which is $5,900. That is $10,400 before the cap, so the $8,000 maximum applies. Add the premium: $5,940 + $8,000 = $13,940.

Plan B is $1,040 cheaper. A lower coinsurance rate and a lower maximum beat the copays in the year when the maximum is reached.

Year Plan A total Plan B total Cheaper
Quiet $6,720 $6,730 About even (A by $10)
Moderate $9,120 $9,940 A by $820
Hospital $14,980 $13,940 B by $1,040

Neither plan wins every year. The right choice depends on which row looks more like your next 12 months, and on how much you value having a smaller worst case.

Adding a regular brand drug

Suppose the person also takes one preferred brand drug every month, with no other claims in the year. On Plan A that is 12 x $45 = $540 a year. On Plan B the person pays the full $300 each month because the $4,500 deductible is never reached by this alone: 12 x $300 = $3,600. Including the premium, Plan A is $6,480 + $540 = $7,020 and Plan B is $5,940 + $3,600 = $9,540. Plan A is $2,520 cheaper. A single drug can swing the choice more than anything else in the table.

What the table cannot show

Several features sit outside a summary table, and they can change the answer.

  • Family deductibles. Some plans have an embedded deductible, where each person has an individual deductible inside the family deductible. Others use an aggregate deductible, where the whole family amount must be met before the plan pays. The difference changes the math for a household with one high-cost member. See embedded deductible.
  • Cost-sharing reductions. If your income is below 250% of the poverty level and you buy a silver plan through the marketplace, you may be eligible for a version of the plan with a lower deductible and a lower out-of-pocket maximum. The silver variants for the lowest income groups in plan year 2027 have limits as low as $4,000 for one person (CMS 2027 parameters). That can make silver better than other metal levels. Ask the marketplace which variant your income unlocks before comparing.
  • Network and referral rules. An HMO may require referrals; a PPO may not. A hospital your family relies on might be in one network and out of the other.
  • Prior authorization and step therapy. A drug can be on the formulary and still require approval or a cheaper drug first.
  • Preventive care. Non-grandfathered plans must cover preventive services without cost sharing, so these visits should not drive the choice.

A decision list by how you use care

Use this list as a starting point, and then plug in your own numbers.

  1. If you rarely see a doctor and take no regular prescription, the plan with the lower premium and the lower worst case is usually the more sensible comparison. In the quiet year above the plans tied.
  2. If you have predictable visits, physical therapy, or a monthly drug, and your doctors and drugs are covered by both, a copay-first plan often costs less.
  3. If you expect a procedure, a birth, or a hospital stay, check how soon each plan reaches its out-of-pocket maximum and compare the two maximums. The plan with the lower coinsurance and lower maximum often wins the year.
  4. If you want to use an HSA, you need an HSA-eligible plan. The tax savings are real, but they only help if you can afford to put money in. Read how to compare health plans: premium, deductible, network and drugs for a broader view.
  5. If one plan has your doctor, hospital, or drug and the other does not, the network and the formulary outweigh everything in the table.
  6. If the two plans are close in every other way, choose the one with the lower out-of-pocket maximum, because the worst case is the part you cannot plan around.

A short process for real plans

  1. List the care you expect: visits per year, regular drugs, any known procedure, therapy.
  2. Open the summary of benefits and coverage for each plan. The How to read a Summary of Benefits and Coverage guide explains the format.
  3. Look up your doctors, hospital and each drug on both plans.
  4. Fill in a quiet, moderate and hospital year for each plan, as in the example. The health plan comparison calculator can speed up the arithmetic.
  5. Check that the premium you use already includes your tax credit.
  6. If you are still stuck, a navigator or licensed broker can walk through the comparison at no cost to you.

Mistakes that skew the comparison

A few habits make two plans look more different, or more alike, than they are.

  • Comparing premiums before credits. Use the price you would actually pay after the tax credit, because the credit is the same for both plans and the gap is what matters.
  • Counting the deductible as the cost. The deductible is only one piece. Add the coinsurance after it, up to the out-of-pocket maximum, to see the real bad-year figure.
  • Using last year's care as a forecast. A year with a new baby, a surgery, an injury or a new drug looks nothing like the year before. Plan for what is scheduled or likely, not only for what happened.
  • Forgetting that the choice lasts a year. Outside open enrollment you generally cannot switch plans without a qualifying event, so a plan that is wrong for a hospital year stays wrong all year.
  • Trusting a directory without checking. Provider directories are sometimes out of date. Confirm with the office and ask which plan name and network they mean.

Key takeaways

  • The credit follows the benchmark plan, not the plan you choose, so the premium gap between two silver plans is entirely yours.
  • Same metal level does not mean the same cost for you: in the invented example the plans tied in a quiet year, Plan A won a moderate year by $820 and Plan B won a hospital year by $1,040.
  • A regular brand drug can swing the choice by itself, so check each plan's tier for every drug you take.
  • Network and formulary come before price: a cheaper plan that excludes your doctor or drug costs more.
  • If your income is low enough for cost-sharing reductions, compare the silver variants before comparing other metal levels.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic