Blog
How to read a state complaint ratio before I pick an insurer
How complaints per premium or per member are counted, why big insurers draw more complaints, what confirmed means, and a worked two-insurer comparison.
When you compare insurers, one of the few outside checks on how they treat members is the complaint record kept by your state insurance department and compiled by the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC). A raw count of complaints is almost useless, because a company with a million members will have more complaints than one with ten thousand. What helps is a ratio: complaints compared with the insurer's size. Even then the number needs careful reading.
This post shows how complaint counts are built, how the common ratios work, what "confirmed" means, and how to compare two insurers with an example. The two insurers in the example are hypothetical and the numbers are invented.
What a complaint record actually counts
A complaint, in this context, is a written or online complaint a consumer files with the state insurance department about an insurer, a policy or an agent. The department logs it, forwards it to the insurer for a response, reviews the answer and closes the file with a recorded outcome. States report their complaint data to the NAIC, which publishes summary information through a consumer search tool, and many state departments publish their own reports too.
What gets logged varies by state. Typical categories include claim handling (delays, denials, partial payments), policyholder service, underwriting and rating, marketing and sales, and cancellations. A record may show the reason, the coverage type and how it was resolved.
Key limits to remember:
- Only fully insured, state-regulated coverage shows up. Complaints about self-funded employer plans mostly go to the federal Department of Labor, and Medicare Advantage complaints go to the federal Medicare program, so they are not in state data. A big insurer's state record can miss most of its employer and Medicare business.
- Not every unhappy member complains. The count reflects people who knew they could, bothered to file and had a reason the department accepted as a complaint.
- Time periods differ. Counts are for a specific year or multi-year span. Check the dates.
- Legal entity matters. Data is often reported for the specific licensed company in your state, which may differ from the brand on the card or the parent company. Look for the entity that actually issues your plan.
The ratios, in plain terms
Complaint index (complaints relative to premium)
A common measure compares an insurer's share of complaints with its share of premium in the same market. If a company writes 40% of the premium and receives 30% of the complaints, it is getting fewer than its "fair share." The NAIC's complaint index works on this idea: a value of 1.00 means the company's share of complaints equals its share of premium, a value above 1.00 means a larger share of complaints than premium and below 1.00 means a smaller share. Exact definitions of the market, the coverage type and the time period are given where the data is published, so read them.
Complaints per member, or per 1,000 members
Some states and reports use members instead of premium: complaints divided by the number of covered people, often expressed per 1,000 members. Members are an easier unit to picture, but they treat a young, healthy member and an older, high-cost member the same.
Why not just count complaints?
Consider the arithmetic. If Insurer A has 200,000 members and Insurer B has 8,000, A will almost always have more complaints. To know whether members of one have a worse experience, the count needs a denominator.
What "confirmed" means
States may classify closed complaints by outcome. In NAIC data, a "confirmed" complaint generally means the regulator reviewed it and found the insurer had violated a law, regulation or contract term, or had made a mistake that was corrected. Some departments use other labels, such as "justified" or "company action taken." Complaints that were not confirmed include ones where the insurer acted properly under the policy, ones that were misunderstandings and ones where the regulator lacked authority.
Why it matters: a high total of complaints with few confirmed means many disputes ended with the insurer right. A moderate count with a high confirmed share suggests that the problems regulators found were real. Both numbers are useful, and neither tells you what will happen to your claim. Not every state publishes the confirmed figure; check how your state labels outcomes.
A worked comparison with two labeled hypothetical insurers
The figures below are invented for illustration. They are not real insurers.
Suppose a state's individual health market in a given year looks like this:
- Total premium written by all insurers: $2,000,000,000.
- Total complaints: 4,000.
Two insurers within it:
| Item | Big Insurer | Small Insurer |
|---|---|---|
| Premium written | $800,000,000 | $40,000,000 |
| Members | 200,000 | 8,000 |
| Complaints | 1,200 | 100 |
| Confirmed complaints | 240 | 10 |
Step 1: raw counts
Big Insurer has 1,200 complaints and Small Insurer has 100, so Big has twelve times as many. If you stopped here, you would think Big is far worse. That would be a mistake, because Big is much larger.
Step 2: complaint index
- Big's share of premium: $800,000,000 ÷ $2,000,000,000 = 40%.
- Big's share of complaints: 1,200 ÷ 4,000 = 30%.
- Big's index: 30% ÷ 40% = 0.75.
- Small's share of premium: $40,000,000 ÷ $2,000,000,000 = 2%.
- Small's share of complaints: 100 ÷ 4,000 = 2.5%.
- Small's index: 2.5% ÷ 2% = 1.25.
On this measure, Big is below the market average (0.75) and Small is above it (1.25), even though Big has twelve times the complaints.
Step 3: complaints per 1,000 members
- Big: 1,200 ÷ 200 = 6 complaints per 1,000 members.
- Small: 100 ÷ 8 = 12.5 complaints per 1,000 members.
The picture is the same: Small has more complaints relative to its size.
Step 4: confirmed complaints
- Big: 240 ÷ 1,200 = 20% of its complaints were confirmed.
- Small: 10 ÷ 100 = 10% were confirmed.
- Confirmed per 1,000 members: Big 240 ÷ 200 = 1.2; Small 10 ÷ 8 = 1.25.
Here the story shifts. Small has a higher overall complaint rate, but Big's share of confirmed complaints is higher, and per member the confirmed rates are nearly equal (1.2 versus 1.25). A reader who looked only at the index would conclude Small is worse. A reader who looked at the confirmed rate would see them as about equal.
Step 5: the caution about small numbers
Small has only 100 complaints and 10 confirmed. A few cases in either direction can move its ratio a lot. If it had received 40 fewer complaints, its index would fall below 1.00. When an insurer is small, look at several years before drawing a conclusion. The post Is a small or new health insurer safe to buy from? Checking financial strength discusses the question from the financial-strength side.
The lesson is not that either insurer is good or bad. It is that raw counts mislead, ratios help and the type of complaint matters.
How to find and read the data
- Go to your state insurance department's site, and look for consumer complaint data or "company complaint reports." The guide how to compare health insurers: ratings, complaints and service lists the other checks to pair with it.
- Use the NAIC's consumer search tool on its website. Search the insurer by name, choose the state and the line of coverage (health or individual), and read the complaint information, including the time period and the legal name.
- Check the entity. Find the insurer's legal name on your plan documents and make sure the complaint record refers to that entity in your state.
- Read the reasons. A record dominated by claim-denial complaints says something different from one dominated by agent or marketing complaints. The guide why health claims get denied: the most common reasons explains the usual reasons for denials.
- Look at several years if the site lets you, so one unusual year does not mislead.
- Compare within the same coverage type. Individual-market complaints are not comparable to group or Medicare complaints.
If you have a complaint of your own, the process is in how to file a complaint with your state insurance department, and what happens afterward is in After I file a complaint with the state insurance department: what happens next.
Reading the reasons behind the numbers
The reason codes in a complaint record often tell you more than the total. These are general patterns, not rules.
| Reason category | What it might point to | A question it raises |
|---|---|---|
| Claim delays or denials | Slow processing, strict medical necessity reviews, or disputes over what the plan covers | Do the denials get overturned on appeal? |
| Prior authorization | Approval rules that slow care | How long do approvals take, and are urgent cases expedited? |
| Billing and premium problems | Errors in billing, grace periods or cancellations | Are payments posted on time? |
| Network or directory problems | Providers listed as in-network who were not | Is the directory kept current? |
| Marketing and sales | Misleading descriptions by agents or ads | Is this about the insurer or a particular agency? |
| Customer service | Long waits, lost paperwork | Is there a clear escalation path? |
A company whose complaints cluster in one category may have a specific, fixable problem. A company with scattered complaints across all categories has a different profile. Neither pattern predicts your own experience, but the mix tells you which questions to ask.
If one insurer's ratio is high
A high ratio is a reason to look closer, not a reason to rule out a plan.
- Check whether the high count came from a single year, a single event such as a system conversion or an unusual hospital dispute, or from several years in a row.
- Compare it with the other insurers in the same state and coverage type, not with a national average.
- Look at how many complaints were confirmed.
- Ask the insurer, a broker or a navigator what changed and whether it has been fixed. The insurer's answer is a claim to check, not a fact.
- Weigh it with network, drugs and total cost. A plan with a modestly worse complaint ratio that includes all of your doctors can still be the better fit for you.
Equally, a low ratio does not prove a good experience. It may reflect members who do not file complaints, or a book of coverage that rarely produces disputes.
What complaint data cannot tell you
- How your claim will go. The ratio is an average over thousands of members.
- Whether the insurer's network includes your doctors. That is a separate check.
- The cost of the plan. Premium, deductible and drug coverage do not appear in complaint records.
- Why the number is what it is. A company that handles a large share of members who file complaints about a single hospital dispute can look different from one with scattered problems.
- Problems in coverage the state does not regulate. Self-funded employer plans and Medicare Advantage are outside most state data.
Pair complaint records with other evidence: financial-strength and quality ratings (see Insurer ratings explained: AM Best, NCQA, CMS stars and J.D. Power), your own network and drug checks and local experience. The health insurer comparison tool on this site brings some of these together.
Questions to ask a broker or navigator
- Do you see complaints, or particular kinds of problems, with this insurer in my county?
- Is this plan state-regulated or self-funded? (State data only covers the first.)
- How does the insurer handle appeals and prior authorization in practice?
A licensed broker or a marketplace navigator can answer from experience, though their view is partial; ask whether they are paid by the insurer.
Key takeaways
- Raw complaint counts reflect company size; use a ratio such as the complaint index or complaints per 1,000 members.
- In the invented example, Big Insurer has twelve times the complaints of Small Insurer but an index of 0.75 versus 1.25, and complaints per 1,000 members of 6 versus 12.5.
- A confirmed complaint means the regulator found the insurer at fault; the confirmed rate can tell a different story from the total (1.2 versus 1.25 per 1,000 in the example).
- State data covers only state-regulated coverage, so self-funded employer plans and Medicare Advantage are mostly missing.
- Small insurers' ratios move a lot with a few cases; look at several years and at the specific legal entity.